With the fantasy football regular season coming to an end, I thought it might be an appropriate enough time to take time out from bashing annoying broadcasters for a week. Though the prospect of the huge showdown Thursday night being called by Bryant Grumbel, er, I mean Grumble, is weighing on my mind. It’s kind of like being invited to the Playboy mansion and taking your mother in-law along. But I digress.
No, for this week’s blog I think it might be time to revisit the week 4 blog. That was the one where I printed the letter from young Matt, who graciously took the time to ridicule my predictions. He found my 10 Players to Avoid Column I wrote in July to be lacking in accuracy after 3 weeks of evidence.
I used that letter he sent to me and the entire staff here at the Huddle as a lesson about quick judgements. Here was the readers report card on my Players to Avoid predictions after just 3 weeks of play:
Shaun Alexander – WRONG, #9 RB
Willis Mcgahee – WRONG, #16 RB
Randy Moss – WRONG, #1 WR
Chad Johnson – WRONG, #2 WR
Reggie Brown – Correct
Michael Vick – easy one
Alge Crumpler – WRONG, #6 TE
All Jaguars except Jones-Drew – WRONG, Jones-Drew is the one NOT to have
Larry Johnson – Correct (the only tough call he made!)
All Chiefs – Correct
But look how things have changed. Moss (#2 overall) and McGahee (#6 RB) were awful picks to be sure. And you might argue that there were Chiefs (namely Gonzo and Bowe) who were great draft picks. Here is how the rest fared:
Chad Johnson I did not suggest CJ would bust, but speculated that Housh would be a better value. Even after CJ’s huge 40 point effort in week 12, he still trails Housh by 24 points, and Housh has been the more consistant play. Gold!
Shaun Alexander #42 RB
Reggie Brown #46 WR
Vick never made training camp
Crumpler #20 TE
Jaguars except MJD MJD #10 RB ` Rg Williams #49 ` WR Garrard #20 ` QB F. Taylor #33 RB
Larry Johnson #18 RB and sinking
All performing below their draft positions. 7 out of 10 right. 70% again. Yeah, I think I even predicted that I would be 70% right on my predictions. I nailed two first round draft busts.
Of course, while I am patting myself on the back, and kicking poor misguided Matt to the curb one more time, I should probably mention that you could have overcome most any of these draft day disasters if you had simply ignored my comments about Randy Moss and drafted him anyway. As a matter of fact NOT drafting Moss probably cost a lot of you a chance at a championship. So I suppose I should check my ego at the door about this…….
and move onto reviewing what I said about Preist Holmes 5 weeks ago:
October 17
Don’t bother going out and getting Priest Holmes off your waiver wire. The Chiefs are going to ask him to suit up, but he isn’t likely to do much. This is nothing more than a tug of war over dollars that has turned ugly. Now Priest Holmes (who admittedly was not anywhere near football shape coming into camp) may actually be asked take some carries. I’m not convinced it is safe for Holmes to be in the game. I fear for his safety. But Holmes is intent on cashing his checks til the bitter end, and that is all this is about. Don’t get caught up in it. It can’t end well.
Tragic but true, I saw that one coming.
—–
My sleepers and busts picks a couple of weeks before the season was decent overall:
Sleepers (#=current PPR ranking / (where drafted by position in Huddle writers league)
Roethlisberger #5 QB (drafted 17)
Kitna #10 (7)
Campbell #11 (24)
Cutler #13 (10)
———-
Deuce (out) (22)
Jacobs #31 (20)
Norwood #44 (28)
Washington #45 (47)
Dayne #37 (55)
———-
Cotchery #27 (23)
Jennings #17 (35)
Crayton #37 (60)
D. Henderson (ugh)
———-
Cooley #5 (7)
V Davis #14 (3)
Scheffler #16 (no action until week 5) (18)
Busts
Leinart (out)
Eli Manning #12
———-
A. Peterson #5
———-
Mark Clayton #72
———-
Winslow #2 (has stayed healthy much to my amazement)
About half right on that list. Nothing a monkey with a dartboard couldn’t have done.
—-
In one of my earliest blogs this season, I told you about this great draft I had in a WCOFF satellite league when the fantasy Gods finally gave me that elusive first overall pick. What I didn’t realize then was that the guy who got Romo and Moss was the one that had a great draft. Mine was merely good.
I drafted first and took Tomlinson. At the next turn I took Fitzgerald and Wayne. That basically made my season right there. The interesting thing is though, I used the same basic draft philosophy in another satellite league where I drafted 9th, substituting Westbrook for Tomlinson. As it turned out, that was a blessing. But guess who the two receivers I took at the other end were? Teammates of the first pair. Boldin and Harrison. A slow painful death to 6-5. I swear I never saw it coming.
The Tomlinson team is playoff bound barring any disasters the next two weeks, while the other one flamed out with the painful trio of Boldin, Harrison and Evans. Sheer fate. At the other end of the draft those guys weren’t even options most times, just because of the way most drafts played out.
I liked all of the guys I targeted and drafted on these teams. I managed to get the right combination on one team. Fate was kind. That team is 3rd in the league and playoff bound. Not quite the juggernaut I thought it would be, but then I didn’t anticipate the biggest coup of the draft would be Brady and Moss, Romo and Owens. Those that did are the juggernauts this season. The rest of us are just hoping to get a shot to knock them off any given Sunday in December.
I’m in pretty good position to make the playoffs in 3 of my 5 leagues, but nothing will be settled for sure until this weekend. It’s getting down to it guys and gals. It’s almost one and done time. Best of luck to you all and I hope maybe I helped you with a nugget or two somewhere along the way.
It certainly has been a challenging year. If you have guided your team through the rapids this year to make it to the playoffs you should give yourself a nice round of applause. And if you didn’t listen to me and drafted Randy Moss, you will probably dust me in the playoffs, so give yourself an extra big hand. Man, that is going to hurt………….
And for those of you out of the playoffs and looking toward next season I have a few quick thoughts on a couple of players:
Earnest Graham and Cadillac Williams: I think that the Bucs have decided to roll with Graham as their guy. And just to prove that conviction I dropped Cadillac Williams in my dynasty league. I have Graham, and decided not to roster Caddy any longer. It is like owning a stock that steadily goes down in value. I stopped the bleeding too late. Of course this caused quite a stir in the league. While most of them would not offer anything in trade, several of the leaguemates apparently thought me quite mad to drop such a valuable asset as Williams. I thought nothing of it. When I make up my mind about a player, I roll with it. And given Cadillacs ongoing ineffectiveness and health issues, I do not see him as worthy of a roster spot at this time. He is a name, and that is all. I am convinced he will never be what we thought he might me. Dead weight. Move on.
Kenny Watson and Rudi Johnson: Here is another pair I own in dynasty. This one is not as cut and dry as the Caddy one. Rudi has looke more like his old self since finally coming back from injury, but Watson has cut out his niche in the gameplan. The Bengals seem to be focusing on the run a lot more lately (and surprise, they have looked better as a team both offensively and defenesively) so Rudi owners can plan on him continuing to be devalued as yet another RBBC is born.
Patrick Crayton, Terry Glenn, Sam Hurd: Those in dynasty leagues should be particularly aware of this situation. The Cowboys will need to decide if they want to outbid other teams for Crayton’s services. There is no way we can know if they will. Crayton is owned in most all dynasty leagues, as he figures to probably start for some team next season. But if the Cowboys let him walk, and Glenn is done, is it not possible that Sam Hurd could emerge as the #2 WR in the Romo led offense? Granted, with Witten and Owens hauling most of the passes, the Cowboys WR2 is not spectacular. But that guy is always an Owens or Witten injury away from being a great play. If you have a dead roster spot (and shame on you if you do) you might want to get a jump on the Hurd.
Adrian Peterson is a popular name for NFC North starting running backs. There are two of them. The lesser known is just about to get the audition his legion of supporters have been screaming for. I can’t imagine he is available in any serious dynasty leagues, but on the odd chance that he is, I would give that serious consideration. I have been holding Peterson since I picked him up off waivers before the season started. Going into the playoffs, it was a fortuitous time for him to emerge as a starter. In leagues where he is a free agent, there will be a bull rush to get him. Possibly a very valuable pick up just under the waiver wire. He has his “big break”, now let’s see what he can do with it.