Nothing is better than entering into the next season of your dynasty league with a roster brimming with starting running backs. How delightful! Should I start them? Should I trade them? Oh look, that team doesn’t have any - pity!
But the 2008 NFL draft didn’t take potshots at starting running backs. It approached the NFL backfields with a shotgun and by the time the second round - THE SECOND ROUND - already seven starters in the league were left scratching their head while fantasy owners reviewed their rosters like the dead and dying from a battlefield report. Let’s see who just lost fantasy value.
Darren McFadden (OAK) - The 1.04 pick in the draft made holding Justin Fargas no longer all that attractive even if he did sign a nice contract a few months ago. Lamont Jordan and Dominic Rhodes are just waiting for the phone call.
Jonathan Stewart (CAR) - The 1.13 pick was a mild surprise but only because it is year three of fantasy owners waiting for DeAngelo Williams to get his shot at being the starter. Not going to happen. He’ll still play but Stewart is everything that Foster never was and Williams apparently will never be.
Felix Jones (DAL) - Enough with the crying about why Julius Jones took carries away from the always more productive Marion Barber. We’re still facing Barber and Jones only this time it is Felix who was the first pick of the Cowboys and just the third overall RB taken in a draft considered rich in running backs. Barber still plays and still scores touchdowns. That whole pipe dream about 25 carries a game just flew out the top of Texas Stadium though. Oh yeah, hold out longer Barber. Not like the Cowboys have any other choice… no wait. Now they do.
Rashard Mendenhall (PIT) - This was a surprise but so was Mendenhall being available at the 1.23 pick. No blaming the Steelers for taking the RB that some had #2 on their draft board and that comes in with less speed than Parker but more of everything else. This includes healthy limbs. This was probably the toughest one to swallow for dynasty team owners. Take a top ten RB and now there’s no telling how much Parker gets used. And no major rush to get him back into the lineup. Fast Willie meet prototypical Mendenhall.
Chris Johnson (TEN) - This is maybe not that bad. Sure, it says that the Titans whiffed when they took Chris Henry in the second round last year but Lendale White can now return to what he does best - plow into the lone and offer the thunder to Johnson’s lightning. Two runners that are completely different but both will cut into what the other would do alone. Nice move for the Titans, not so much if you were banking on White this year.
Matt Forte (CHI) - Hey, it could be worse for Cedric Benson. At least the Bears waited until the second round before taking a runner that is effectively the same as Benson. The least this will do is offer a muddled backfield and lower numbers but then again, they were already among the lowest last year for Benson. Chances that Matt Forte hires a family friend as an agent and then holds out until September? Less than zero.
Ray Rice (BAL) - This may not be that bad since Willis McGahee actually ran well last year and the Ravens could always use a solid back-up but many people were high on Rice and feel that he has NFL quality skills. McGahee is safe… for now…
That’s arguably five or six veteran RB’s that are almost certainly looking at less work in 2008. And that means less points for your team. It only serves to make yet more teams lean towards tandem backfields. The great news is that there are a lot more running backs that had fantasy significance. The bad news is that there are even less with any difference making scoring for your team.
Tough to rely on any RB from year to year it seems. And it only gets worse.
Sniff… I love you LaDainian…
