2003
Player Rankings: Running Backs
Updated: September 2, 2003
|
| |
THE REST OF THE RB RANKINGS >>
| TIER 1 - The Studs |
NFL |
Bye |
Upside |
Risk |
Ht |
Wt |
Age |
Exp |
|
Auction % |
| |
1 |
Tomlinson, LaDainian |
SD |
6 |
|
|
5-10 |
221 |
23 |
2 |
|
35 |
| |
In his second season, Tomlinson
increased his total yards from 1603 to 2172 and his touchdowns
from 10 to 15. He is only 23 years old. The prototypical
size for a runner, LT is in a system that will maximize
his talents and unlike so many other teams, the Chargers
do not make him share. The next best rusher on their team
was Terrell Fletcher with 26 carries for the year. With
this young stud the focus of his offense, both powerful
and fast and with a great track record of durability,
it does not get any lower risk and maybe not higher reward
than Tomlinson. Of the top three backs, Tomlinson is the
one without any question marks at all. |
| |
2 |
Portis, Clinton |
DEN |
10 |
|
|
5-11 |
205 |
21 |
1 |
|
35 |
| |
At this time last season,
the debate was Gary, Anderson or Portis. Case closed.
Portis went on a tear starting week five that included
nine games with 100 total yards, four games that exceeded
150 yards and twice he topped 200 yards in a game. In
his final five weeks, he averaged 165 yards and two touchdowns
a game. Portis is a bit lighter than many runningbacks
but those fewer pounds made him lightning fast when he
found a running lane. When Portis clears the safety, opponents
can get ready for the kickoff. He had eight 100 yard rushing
games in total and averaged six yards per carry over the
final seven weeks. With a favorable rushing schedule and
very fresh legs, consider Portis as 1B to Tomlinson. |
| |
3 |
Williams, Ricky |
MIA |
4 |
|
|
5-10 |
228 |
24 |
4 |
|
35 |
| |
It may have taken four years,
three coaches and two teams, but Williams finally met
all expectations by leading the NFL last season with 1853
rushing yards and gained 17 touchdowns in the process.
In an era where multiple backs are being used in offenses,
Williams is a wonderful return to the grind it out bruisers
and somewhat surprisingly, Williams showed a new burst
and speed in Miami that had been missing. Williams also
finally had a season without any missed games or nagging
injuries and turned in ten 100 yard rushing games including
two 200 yard games. While his schedule will be tougher
than Tomlinson or Portis, there is no question that Williams
will get a heavy load and respond well since he actually
got better as the last season progressed. |
| |
4 |
Holmes, Priest |
KC |
9 |
 |
 |
5-9 |
213 |
29 |
6 |
|
32 |
| |
In case there were any doubters
about Holmes' 2001 season of 2169 total yards and 10 TD's,
Priest suddenly became the next Faulk (just in time too)
by burning the NFL for 2287 yards and 24 touchdowns last
season. Oh yes, he did that in 14 games. Holmes would
be the unquestioned #1 this season had it not been for
a hip injury that required offseason surgery in March.
Holmes' accomplishments last season read like a fantasy
football wish list and his health will be of paramount
interest this summer. He is expected to be ready in time
for training camp and has been described as recovering
well (in the way that no one believes until it is seen).
Holmes turns 30 this year but has much less miles on the
odometer than other backs. He just needs to heal like
a young man, not someone in his thirties. Time will tell.
Raised 5th to 4th (07/28/03) - Holmes has looked
good in training camp so far and with encouraging signs,
he warrants the move up one spot. |
| |
5 |
Faulk, Marshall |
STL |
5 |
 |
 |
5-10 |
211 |
30 |
9 |
|
32 |
| |
As the first pick in the draft
last season, Faulk was a major disappointment. He ended
with 1490 yards and 10 scores but you expect and deserve
far better from a first pick. Consider too that Faulk
had 535 yards and 6 of the touchdowns in a three game
span mid-season. Faulk was unable to prevent the spanking
that St. Louis received last season due to line problems
and quarterback injuries. He represents the biggest risk/reward
player in the draft along with Priest Holmes. At the age
of 30 and with 16,359 total yards, 120 touchdowns and
almost 3000 touches in his career, perhaps he is feeling
the effects of time in an offense that no longer can produce
45 points every game. He has missed at least two games
a season the past three years and played at less than
100% in many others. Then again, even Marshall Faulk alone
is not enough to be successful in the NFL and line injuries
coupled with QB problems have a big impact. If you take
Faulk you are bottling up two roster spots since you must
get Gordon. And hope those two games he misses in 2003
are not weeks 15 and 16. |
| |
6 |
Alexander, Shaun |
SEA |
4 |
|
|
5-11 |
229 |
25 |
3 |
|
32 |
| |
The season started mighty
slow for Alexander in 2002 and with an average of 70 yards
and only one score in the first three games, it seemed
Alexander was a bust. In week 4, he fixed his average
by gaining 231 yards and four touchdowns against the Vikings.
The holdout by Walter Jones with other OL injuries finally
resolved themselves and when the dust settled, Alexander
had gained 1635 total yards with 18 touchdowns. He effectively
mirrored 2001, he just used the last 13 games to do it.
The good part of Alexander is that he turns in monster
games. He had four Sundays of over 150 yards and six times
he scored two or more touchdowns. The problem is that
he is not as consistent. He also had eight games without
a score or 100 yards. He only did that in three starts
in 2001. Alexander has all the pedigree of any of the
top backs and will not have the same line problems this
season. He has been durable and the Seahawks have a more
favorable rushing schedule. Look for Alexander to continue
to still provide the occasional monster game and to make
the games in between better this season as well. Dropped
4th to 6th (07/28/03) - The Pro Bowl left tackle
Walter Jones has again been slapped with the franchise
tag and last year when it happened, he held out the first
three games which contributed to Alexander's slow start.
Looks like more of the same may be happening since Jones
did not report to camp on time again. |
| |
7 |
McAllister, Deuce |
NO |
10 |
 |
 |
6-1 |
221 |
24 |
2 |
|
30 |
| |
Even with Ricky Wiliiams shining
in the Florida sun, the Saints could not have been happier
with their decision to go with Deuce. With 1740 yards
and 16 touchdowns, McAllister was an integral part of
the offense and 11 times exceeded 100 total yards in a
game. His numbers took a dip down during the final three
weeks along with the rest of the team but he still managed
to be a worthy fantasy starter except for his 26 yard
meltdown in CIN in week 16 when the Saints forgot to show
up and Brooks was playing injured. McAllister will perform
as a top three back in many weeks but his risk is that
he has a history of injuries. Nothing major, but he missed
a game last season due to an ankle injury and then slapped
the fantasy owners who sat him in week 10 when he magically
went from questionable to stud immediately after the kickoff.
In college he had a history of ankle and shoulder problems
and playing on the hard carpet is no help. McAllister
will also be facing a tough schedule this season though
it starts out lightly and then later gets tough. Still,
his solid performances in so many games makes him a definite
Tier 1 player and a definite step up from the second tier
of runners. |
| |
8 |
James, Edgerrin |
IND |
7 |
 |
 |
6-0 |
214 |
24 |
4 |
|
24 |
| |
James, like Emmitt Smith and
Terrell Davis, is a big name from the recent past and
unlike them he is only turning 25 this year. After starting
out with two seasons of 2000+ yards and 17+ touchdowns,
James was the man in the summer of 2001. Through the first
six games that season, he had averaged 142 yards per game
and scored three times. And then he blew out his knee.
Since then fantasy owners have delighted themselves with
Dominic Rhodes (2001) and then James Mungro (2002). On
the heels of reconstructive surgery, James was drafted
as the consensus #6 RB last season by fantasy owners hopeful
that all the news that he was nearing 100% was true. It
wasn't. More than that he suffered from rib, hamstring
and high ankle sprains last season. James is almost two
years removed from his initial knee injury and is reported
to be recovered from his many maladies. He has a very
tough schedule to face but was more than enough to beat
good defenses his first two seasons when healthy. In the
words of your high school sweetheart - "you say the
right things, but how many times do you expect me to take
you back?" Anyone with the production that he had
two years ago is a worthwhile gamble, the quesion is how
high is his risk/reward compared to other runningbacks
selected around him.? If he continues to look good in
the summer, he will move up but regardless be aware that
although youth favors him, statistical probablilty does
not. Raised (08/04/03)
- James has been looking very much like his old self again
in trainingcamp - that's the old self that was a RB monster
in 2000. The knee appears healthy again and all the nagging
injuries of 2002 have healed. He bumps up one spot but
his injury history prevents him from rising further. James
has been making a great risk play towards the end of the
first round in most drafts that could pay off handsomely,
or could just again be frustrating.
Raised (08/06/03) - The Colts are now practicing
with James sometimes split out as a receiver and are expanding
his role in the passing game. All favorable signs that
Edgerrin is back to form. |
| TIER 2 - Best Bets |
NFL |
Bye |
Upside |
Risk |
Ht |
Wt |
Age |
Exp |
|
Auction % |
| |
9 |
Green, William |
CLE |
9 |
 |
|
6-0 |
221 |
23 |
1 |
|
24 |
| |
The numbers from his 2002
rookie campaign are not impressive - exactly 1000 total
yards and six touchdowns. Green muddled through the first
nine weeks with only 166 yards, one touchdown and a 2.3
yards per carry average. Instead of taking Cleveland by
storm, he was quickly swirling down the drain. The first
RB taken in the 2001 draft, he was considered to be too
tentative, thinking too much or an outright bust. Something
clicked in week 11 after the bye week. From then on he
averaged 120 yards a game and scored five times. He failed
to get 100 yards or a touchdown only once in Baltimore
in that time. With his stumbling start behind him and
solid performances in his past seven games, Green is ready
to meet expectations against one of the lighter schedules
for runningbacks. |
|
10 |
Green, Ahman |
GB |
8 |
|
 |
6-0 |
217 |
26 |
5 |
|
20 |
| |
With 1637 yards and nine touchdowns
over 14 games, Green had roughly the same per game averages
as 2001. Last season he was a consensus #2 or #3 RB in
the drafts, so why the drop here? Green's projections
are lowered not only because of the injuries he was gaining
last season (bruised kneecap, strained quadricep), but
also because the Packers intend on making greater use
of Najeh Davenport to keep Green healthy and reduce his
load. His durability and lessened workload drops him,
but a nice schedule and solid performance when healthy
still makes him a solid pick at RB. Falls 8th to 11th
(7/28/03) - Green was already subjected to the decision
to use Najeh Davenport more to spell him and keep him
healthy and in training camp so far, Davenport has looked
very impressive. Given the risk of losing potential short
scores to the burly Davenport who is looking better, Green
falls because you do not want to squander an early pick
on a RB that seems destined to be used less in games than
last season. |
| |
11 |
Barber, Tiki |
NYG |
4 |
|
 |
5-10 |
200 |
28 |
6 |
|
20 |
| |
In 2002, Barber turned in
his career best season by gaining 1984 total yards with
11 touchdowns. He benefited greatly when Jim Fassell took
over the play calling and Barber produced five games with
over 150 yards. His yardage totals were aided by the 276
yard effort in the last week of the season and it is unusual
for a RB to have 64 catches without a touchdown receiving.
Barber is coming off a career year and his first, more
or less, as a true primary back. At only 200 pounds, there
has always been a concern that he is not big enough for
an every down role and while he did just that last season
with good results, the knock on him in 2001 was that he
slowed down in the second half of the season. With his
receiving yards and rushing ability, Barber will turn
in points each week. The risk is that he will not meet
the career best numbers of last season and that he may
wear down during the season if he continues what was a
heavier load than his five prior seasons in the NFL. |
| |
12 |
Dillon, Corey |
CIN |
6 |
|
|
6-1 |
225 |
28 |
6 |
|
16 |
| |
Dillon deserves
to head up this tier. After six seasons, Dillon has never
gone below around 1400 yards a season, never gets above
around 1700 yards a season and is good for around seven
TD's a year with a high of 13 in 2001. It may not be championship
caliber, but he is consistently an "upper middle
class" pick. He will always get you something every
week and about four or six times a season he will have
a really big game. Consistency from your #2 RB spot is
a good thing. With Marvin Lewis as the new head coach,
the Bengals should be running no less and Dillon has not
missed a game since 1998. Safe, solid and at least twice
a season you get to say "did you check out what Dillon
did on Sunday?" |
| |
13 |
Lewis, Jamal |
BAL |
5 |
|
 |
5-11 |
231 |
23 |
3 |
|
16 |
| |
After blowing his knee during
the preseason of 2001, Lewis recuperated and when he returned
he claimed to be back to form. Evidently he was telling
the truth, since comparing 2002 to his 2000 rookie season
he only had one less carry, 37 less yards rushing, the
same six touchdowns and 148 more receiving yards. Now
there's consistency. Lewis, like Dillon, is a very nice
#2 RB for your team but likely no better. He managed to
gain 90 yards or more in 12 of his 16 weeks last season
but he only scored in four games. Oddly enough, three
of those were two touchdown days. Until the Ravens become
settled at the quarterback position and produce more offense,
Lewis will have limited upside. They just do not get close
enough for many short touchdowns and Lewis has never been
accused of being durable anyway. With either Redman or
the rookie Boller due to start this season, look about
for the same from Lewis. He should be even healthier than
last year but that may just as well mean he is due for
another injury. |
| |
14 |
Davis, Stephen |
CAR |
3 |
 |
|
6-0 |
230 |
29 |
7 |
|
16 |
| |
Starting fresh in Carolina,
Davis is a very good fit for what HC John Fox and OC Dan
Henning are looking for in a power back. Davis should
see over 300 carries and not be pulled at the goal line.
The main reason Davis is not ranked higher is that his
upside will come from rushing the ball and not receptions.
Davis has never caught more than 33 passes in a season
and he may not get that in Carolina. Back in the age when
runningbacks only ran, he would be much higher than this
ranking. There is also some concern regarding his durability
since in seven seasons he has only 2001 when he played
all 16 games. If the line appears solid and Davis looks
to figure into the passing scheme as well, he will undoubtedly
move higher. Update (08/11/03) - Davis looked in
top form on Saturday as he stuck it to his former employer
of the Redskins. He ran for 74 yards on only seven carries
and looked exactly the way that the Panthers wanted him
to look - powerful and tackled well beyond the line of
scrimmage. |
| |
15 |
Henry, Travis |
BUF |
9 |
|
 |
5-9 |
220 |
24 |
2 |
|
16 |
| |
After a mediocre rookie campaign
in 2001 of 899 total yards and four touchdowns, Henry
pumped up his rushing average a full yard to 4.4 and gained
1747 total yards with 14 touchdowns in a breakout season.
The Bills drafted Willis McGahee this season and will
not let their first round pick waste away in future seasons
but most likely McGahee will be placed on the PUP list
this summer and not be available until after week 14 of
the season. You know - when your fantasy playoffs likely
start. But that alone is not enough reason to drop Henry
to this ranking since McGahee may never play this season
or any season. The Bills have stated that they want to
run the ball more this season and that might make Henry
seem even more valuable. It might. But there is concern
that Henry was a beneficiary of what the trio of Bledsoe,
Price and Moulds did to defenses. The Bills already witnessed
their passing game slowing down the second half of 2002
and that was with Price still there. Returning to a more
easily defensible offense with Moulds as the clear weapon
to guard and with an offense that had already cooled,
Henry must face one of the more daunting rushing schedules
in the league. He may rise in the rankings but there is
more risk involved than a glance at last season's stats
suggest. Henry is a solid #2 fantasy back but expecting
#1 RB numbers from him is optimistic. Henry further hurts
himself with a tendency to fumble. |
| TIER 3 - Safe or
Worthy Risk |
NFL |
Bye |
Upside |
Risk |
Ht |
Wt |
Age |
Exp |
|
Auction % |
| |
16 |
Taylor, Fred |
JAX |
7 |
 |
 |
6-1 |
232 |
27 |
5 |
|
16 |
| |
After finally playing a full
16 game season for the first time in his five year career,
Taylor is poised for absolute greatness. Or is it another
flop year? You can never be sure until it is too late.
Though Taylor lasted all sixteen games (he nursed a sprained
ankle the final two weeks) with 1722 total yards and eight
touchdowns, he still was not to his level of 2000 (1630/14)
or his rookie year of 1998 (1644/17) in terms of touchdowns.
And in those years he still missed three and two games
respectively. The problem was that Stacey Mack siphoned
off 9 touchdowns last season and had Taylor kept those
he would have been right at his rookie year's performance.
The problem is that Taylor did make it all 16 games and
the fact that Mack had 98 carries when it counted the
most was a contributor to that. Mack is gone to Houston
now but rookie LaBrandon Toefield is almost the same size
as Mack. Elvis Joseph also lurks. There has been no official
word that HC Jack Del Rio is plotting against fantasy
owners of Taylor, but he has not come out and said he
will not use a short yardage player. There are indications
that the Jaguars will be using new FB Marc Edwards will
be much more involved in Del Rio's offense than Jacksonville
has historically done with a fullback. Taylor's ranking
may change depending on better info on how the backfield
will be used but until then Taylor continues to be a roll
of the dice and thus far he has only performed well in
even-numbered years. Add in a possible QB problem between
Brunell and Leftwich, the continued absence of a suitable
#2 receiver and expecting much more from Taylor is unreasonable
for now. Lowered 15th
to 16th - Taylor has now missed two weeks with a bruised
kneecap and would be an injury concern even if he had
been healthy. His risk goes a little higher with this
latest malady and he looks very much like he will be following
his every other year syndrome - this being an off year. |
| |
17 |
Garner, Charlie |
OAK |
8 |
|
 |
5-10 |
190 |
31 |
9 |
|
16 |
| |
Garner is another runner coming
off a career year and at the age of 31, he needs to get
those on the shelf while he still can. Garner ended with
1903 yards of offense, almost perfectly split 962 rushing
and 941 yards receiving. In the first four weeks while
the NFL marveled at the volume of passes from Gannon,
Garner rang up 596 yards and six touchdowns. He slowed
his pace thereafter, but still managed to score in five
of the remaining 12 games while topping 100 total yards
seven times. Garner comes off a career year and is a definite
risk to not repeat it. Not only is he 31, but he plays
with offensive stars that are even older. Like Barber,
Garner's passing yardage allows him to offer almost no
bad games even if there are less stellar rushing weekends.
His solid 2002 showing makes him worthy of this ranking
but other considerations keep him from rising. |
| |
18 |
George, Eddie |
TEN |
9 |
|
 |
6-3 |
236 |
29 |
7 |
|
12 |
| |
After managing only 1218 total
yards and five scores in 2001, George rewarded fantasy
owners last season with a refreshing 1420 yards and 14
touchdowns last season. Does this mean Eddie has turned
back the clock and 2001 was not the start of a trend but
an aberration? Probably not. George battled through foot
problems and ligament strains but played all 16 games
as he always does. He has not missed a start since his
rookie year in 1996. Though he played all season, George
only topped 100 total yards five times and rushed for
100 only three times. He did score in nine games and five
of them were two touchdown games. But he only averaged
over four yards a carry four times and exceeded 4.3 yards
a carry only once. His volume of touchdowns was a fantasy
boon but was directly related to the back and rib injuries
of Steve McNair. Eddie will likely be drafted earlier
than this and you can be sure that even if injured he
will probably play. But advancing age and declining yards
per carry will translate into closer to the 2001 Eddie
than last season's version. |
| |
19 |
Martin, Curtis |
NYJ |
5 |
|
 |
5-11 |
205 |
30 |
8 |
|
12 |
| |
Martin was a nice surprise
in 2001 when he turned in a career best 1833 total yards
and 10 touchdowns but last season he played much of the
time with excruciating pain from high ankle sprains. He
ended with about 1400 yards and seven touchdowns and Lamont
Jordan was used as the short yardage back. Martin is a
warrior but he is now 30 years old, less durable and has
a good backup in Jordan who comes in to steal the short
yardage scores and rest Curtis. Add on the increased reliance
on the passing game with Pennington and Martin is a risk
this season and likely all future ones. Martin is another
"trip pick" - Lamont Jordan and a bye week filler
must be drafted. Update (08/24/03) - With Pennington
out for an unknown amount of time, the offense is less
likely to get leads that Martin would be used to protect.
He will still be relied on and maybe even heavier now,
but his production will suffer slightly overall. |
| |
20 |
Hambrick, Troy |
DAL |
3 |
 |
 |
6-1 |
233 |
26 |
3 |
|
12 |
| |
In a season with surprisingly
few unknowns at starting runningback, Hambrick is the
one player that not enough is known. In three seasons
with the Cowboys he has had only 198 carries but averaged
4.7 yards. That could be from him being a true sleeper
or that could be from the defenses shifting focus because
Emmitt was gone from the game when Hambrick played. Troy
was given the starting job by default since Emmitt left
and the Cowboys spent money and draft picks in other need
areas. Parcells is focusing on defensive matters most
the first season and will use 2002 to determine if in
fact he has a decent quarterback or runningback. It could
very well be RBBC in Dallas between Hambrick, Aveion Cason,
Michael Wiley and even Richie Anderson who Parcells indicated
would reprise the role he played in New York as a ball
handling fullback. The biggest thing going for Hambrick,
other than his belly, is that he is one of the few unknowns
this year and Parcells prefers to run when he can. The
only thing to be certain of is that Bill Parcells will
use what works. If Hambrick can take advantage of his
opportunity, he could be a great sleeper this year. If
he fails to impress, then Parcells will have zero problem
trying something else. Update (08/04/03) - Hambrick has
lost the weight but is not wowing anyone so far in camp.
Unless his play improves in the eyes of HC Bill Parcells,
he is more likely to fall soon than to rise. (08/11/03)
- Hambrick was unimpressive in the mauling that the Cowboys
allowed in Arizona. Hambrick's rank is not changing yet,
but the offense in Dallas is looking very weak which will
affect Hambrick regardless of how good he may actually
be. Instead of a movement yet, consider this a warning.
He will definitely fall in the rankings without a better
offensive display by Dallas in the next week. |
| TIER 4 - Aging or
In Question |
NFL |
Bye |
Upside |
Risk |
Ht |
Wt |
Age |
Exp |
|
Auction % |
| |
21 |
Dunn, Warrick |
ATL |
8 |
 |
 |
5-9 |
180 |
28 |
6 |
|
12 |
| |
The Falcons acquired Dunn
last year and then drafted T.J. Duckett. One of those
two moves paid off. Dunn gained 927 yards rushing and
377 yards receiving in 2002 with nine touchdowns to help
propel the Falcons back into the playoffs. The original
plan was the old Thunder and Lightning duo - an interesting
combination considering that Dunn (180) is one of the
lightest runningbacks in the entire league and Duckett
(254) is one of the heaviest. The problem was that Duckett
kept getting banged up - a jammed heel and then a knee
sprain with fluid on the knee. When Duckett was healthy,
he had about 2:1 carries over Dunn. When he was not, or
when Atlanta fell behind and went to a one back set using
Dunn, then Warrick took the lead. Dunn responded well
and in the second half of the season had four games with
over 100 total yards gained and on six occasions carried
20 or more times in a game. That is heavy duty for a player
that weighs less than many high school RB's. Just as important,
Dunn provided Michael Vick with a good option for a pass
and had 50 catches on the season. This year the plan is
to feature more of Duckett running and more of Dunn receiving.
Dunn makes a good pick here because not only will he be
always involved in the offense every week, but that if
Duckett again is injured and Warrick needs to carry the
load for a bit, he has proven to be up to the task.
Update (08/18/03) - Dunn falls one spot because Hambrick
looked better this weekend and gave more confidence in
him as a #1 RB in Dallas while Dunn lost Michael Vick
for at least the first four games. There is no big drop
in Dunn's numbers - he will still be relied on the same
but without Vick's running to inspire terror in the secondary,
those short passes to Dunn may likely yield a little less
for the first quarter of the season. |
| |
22 |
Zereoue, Amos |
PIT |
7 |
 |
 |
5-8 |
207 |
26 |
4 |
|
10 |
| |
While many fantasy fans consider
Zereoue their hot sleeper this season, Amos is no lock
for significant additional play this year. As indicated
in the Bettis write-up, the news about his death has been
very premature. Zereoue was the first non-Bettis rushing
leader for the Steelers since 1996. He gained 1103 rushing
yards and tacked on 341 more receiving. But Zereoue had
only four touchdowns last season and they came in only
two games. His best four games, easily, were when Bettis
was out and while he topped 100 total yards in three of
them, he also had 29, 34 or 39 touches to do that. At
5' 8", 207 pounds, it is unlikely that Amos could
handle a season-long load like that even if he had the
opportunity which, at this time, he does not have. Zereoue
is a valuable part of the Steelers offense as a pass catching
third down back and has proven that he can, at least for
a stretch of games, take the full load and deliver. Until
indications are positive that his role is expanding, he
is worth being one of the first backs taken after the
starters are gone.Update (08/20/03) - HC Bill Cowher
named Zereoue as the starting tailback for the Steelers
today. While this brings Amos up sharply in the rankings,
he could rise higher depending on how Bettis is used.
He does not go higher for now with a legitimate concern
that Bettis still figures into to short yardage and valuable
goal line plunges but in a league that gives reception
points, Zereoue goes even higher. |
| |
23 |
Canidate, Trung |
WAS |
8 |
 |
 |
5-11 |
205 |
26 |
3 |
|
10 |
| |
Acquired by the Redskins,
this former first round pick (though at the end of the
round) has his first real opportunity to become a true
starting runningback. Does such a thing exist in Washington
is the next question. Canidate is a good match for the
spread offense employed by Spurrier. The Redskins threw
78 passes to runningbacks last season and this alone makes
Canidate an intriguing pick. Expecting Canidate to become
the exact replacement of Stephen Davis is optimistic at
this point. There has been no solid indication that Canidate
will take the majority of carries and both Ladell Betts
and Kenny Watson showed the ability to receive the ball.
During his final five seasons in Florida, Spurrier never
settled on one runningback and in some seasons spread
the wealth across three runners. Hmmm... Canidate, Watson
and Betts who was drafted in the second round last season.
One.. two.. three! Canidate could surprise but there is
real risk that the Redskins do not settle on a true primary
back and both Betts and Watson have a better size to do
that anyway. This will hopefully become clearer in August
but at this point Canidate is the better bet to turn in
the biggest numbers, if only in a third down role which
is normally how the Skins offense operates anyway. Lowered
(08/04/03) - Canidate still has yet to separate himself
from either Ladell Betts or Kenny Watson and HC Steve
Spurrier has reiterated that he will likely be using all
the running backs this season since there is little discrepancy
between each running back. |
| |
24 |
Hearst, Garrison |
SF |
10 |
|
 |
5-11 |
215 |
32 |
10 |
|
10 |
| |
While Hearst has seen his
yardage decline the past three years and at 32 is one
of the oldest runners in the league, he still turned in
nine touchdowns and 1289 total yards last season. He had
48 receptions while Barlow was very little used in the
passing game. His age, declining effectiveness and a new
offense under Erickson spell risk but San Francisco has
not officially deemed him any less of the offense especially
considering his receiving ability. Hopefully this situation
in San Francisco becomes clearer but it may well not until
the season begins. Hearst can be had as your third fantasy
back in most leagues and he is a safe bet to at least
offer a moderate game. Raised (08/11/03) - Hearst
looked strong in limited play against the Chiefs and also
blocked well. It continues to look like the same as last
season but Barlow's presence prevents Hearst from rising
any farther. |
| |
25 |
Mack, Stacey |
HOU |
5 |
|
|
6-1 |
238 |
27 |
4 |
|
8 |
| |
Mack joins James Allen and
Jonathan Wells in Houston and is already anointed as the
short yardage back. How many of those opportunities will
there be in Houston this season? Mack is a capable back
who has rushed for nine touchdowns in both the last two
years. HC Dom Capers has stated that they may well use
RBBC with Wells and Allen but Mack has easily the best
chance to get significant play. Mack turned down much
more money elsewhere for a chance to become a starting
runningback and whatever good rushing games Houston can
produce, it is a safe bet that Mack will be the major
contributor. In their second season, the Texans want more
points. Raised (08/11/03) - Mack makes the leap
up two spots from a nice effort in the first preseason
game - 14 carries for 49 yards in less than one half.
He ran strong and will be a lock for all short yardage
plays if not significantly more since he was breaking
tackles on Saturday. This jump up is also related to the
slight weakening of Kevan Barlow and Anthony Thomas. |
| |
26 |
Thomas, Anthony |
CHI |
3 |
 |
 |
6-2 |
228 |
25 |
2 |
|
8 |
| |
For a team that once had Neal
Anderson and Walter Payton, the Bears have stumbled through
Rashaan Salaam, Raymont Harris, Edgar Bennett, Curtis
Enis, James Allen and Thomas trying to find the next Bears
legend. Thomas looked the part for one season when he
gained 1183 yards and seven scores as a rookie starting
only ten games. Problem is that in Chicago, a year makes
a big difference to RBs. In 2002, Thomas started 12 games
and when he ended his season with a fractured finger,
he had only one game of 100 yards and eight times had
a YPC of less than 3.5 in a game. He was already being
swapped around for Leon Johnson. The good news here is
that Thomas has taken the news that the RB slot is open
competition this summer and has been privately working
out in the offseason to add muscle and more speed without
giving up overall weight. The bad news here is that the
RB slot is not considered closed and Adrian Peterson averaged
over five yards a carry in limited play last season compared
to Thomas' 3.4 yards per carry. Thomas is the starter
entering camp but is no lock to remain so when camp closes. |
| |
27 |
Buckhalter, C. |
PHI |
3 |
 |
 |
6-0 |
222 |
24 |
2 |
|
8 |
| |
After averaging 4.5 yards
per carry in 2001, Buckhalter was planned to take a greater
rushing load from Staley last season but was derailed
with the NFL's first major injury of 2002. He blew a knee
and spent last season recuperating. Buckhalter is back
in camp and by reports looking recovered from what happened
in spring of 2002. The Eagles will give him opportunities
if he is up to the task but it will not be until August
that we can know better if he is truly back to form. Raised
(08/04/03) - With Staley holding out and Buckhalter
showing that he is fully recovered from his ACL injury,
Buckhalter's role appears to be increasing as is his fantasy
value. Raised (08/15/03) - Based on his impressive
camp work and preseason game, coupled with the hold out
of Staley and the injury to Westbrook and Buckhalter is
about the only sure thing in Philly besides McNabb. Update
(08/20/03) - With every day that Staley holds out,
Buckhalter gets a little more valuable in an offense that
is productive and can make great use of a runner like
Buckhalter. Since Staley might not even be with the Eagles
in a week or two, Buckhalter is a great pickup here and
could rise even higher once Staley is resolved. Update
(08/24/03) - Staley has now reported to camp and it
appears unlikely that he will be traded. Buckhalter will
be sharing with him but is still the safer bet right now
to gain bigger numbers. |
| |
28 |
Barlow, Kevan |
SF |
10 |
 |
 |
6-1 |
238 |
24 |
2 |
|
8 |
| |
Barlow played RBBC with Garrison
Hearst last season and together they notched exactly 2100
yards in total offense and 14 touchdowns. That would be
great for one player but the 49er's have preferred to
share the load in recent years and still have had good
results. The less favorable aspect is that Barlow was
on the short end, gaining 811 yards and only five of the
scores last season. He also has not yet gained over 100
total yards in any single game. What is in his favor is
that Hearst is 32 years old and seems to blow a knee every
few years anyway. The 49er offense has been one of the
top rushing teams (all players combined) in the NFL for
the past several years going back to Garner and Hearst.
Barlow went into last season having worked his body into
great shape and yet still ended up with a knee that forced
him from two games and limited him in two others. With
Dennis Erickson has the new headcoach, Barlow has been
mentioned as taking a heavier rushing load which makes
sense considering Hearst's age but when RBBC works, there
is little reason to change it. This ranking may rise or
fall depending on training camp news. Lowered (08/04/03)
- HC Dennis Erickson has repeated that Garrison Hearst
is the starter for now at least, and that using both backs
again will be used with Hearst getting the most touches.
While all fantasy fans are wanting Barlow to move into
the #1 RB slot in SF, evidently no one is reading the
memo we sent to the Niner braintrust. |
| |
29 |
Smith, Emmitt |
ARZ |
7 |
|
 |
5-9 |
212 |
34 |
13 |
|
6 |
| |
Emmitt incredibly trades his
star for a bird head this season and with that his last
shot to bury the all-time rushing record. Mostly, Arizona
hopes that he can sell a few extra tickets since the only
sellouts were normally when they played the Cowboys. Smith
is old in NFL terms and old in RB terms. His yardage has
declined each season since 1999 and he has missed only
seven games due to injury in the past 13 years. Emmitt
actually could see one last hurrah in yardage but that
would only mean he goes back above 1000 for the season.
On a team that has only one player that performed well
last season (and Emmitt is replacing him), the opportunities
for scores will be even less. Big salutes to one of the
great ones, but if you rely on him for more than a bye
week filler (and make that an early season bye week),
you are asking for too much. |
| TIER 5 - Sliders
& Fighters |
NFL |
Bye |
Upside |
Risk |
Ht |
Wt |
Age |
Exp |
|
Auction % |
| |
30 |
Smith, Antowain |
NE |
10 |
|
|
6-2 |
232 |
31 |
6 |
|
6 |
| |
Coming off a 1349 yard, 13
touchdown season in 2001 in his first season with the
Patriots, Smith spent most of 2002 reminding people that
on his best days he ohnly rises to average. Smith played
all 16 games last year but only once had over 100 total
yards. He ended with 1225 yards and eight scores but 142
yards and three touchdowns came in one game. Otherwise
he averaged around 70 yards a game and scored once every
three games. Smith is already 31 years old and he has
almost no upside. In his favor the Patriots may have had
the fourth worse rushing team in the league last season,
but they have done nothing to change that. With Redmond
and Faulk and Edwards around, look for more RBBC with
Smith the leader of a weak rushing team. Lowered (08/04/03)
-Latest reports are that Kevin Faulk is being considered
for expanded duty at the expense of Smith, as yet more
teams rely on using multiple running backs in the offense. |
| |
31 |
Pittman, Michael |
TB |
4 |
|
|
6-0 |
218 |
28 |
5 |
|
6 |
| |
Pittman is added to the rankings
since he is clearly the best runner in Tampa Bay but he
still has two felony assault charges and a hearing on
his probation violation pending. He could be suspended
or even jailed instead of playing football this fall.
He is a very big risk pick to make in the draft but one
that someone will make. Pittman has a tough rushing schedule
if he does play but will be the best runner in Tampa Bay
if he escapes or delays his legal problems this season.
That is still unknown. |
| |
32 |
Staley, Duce |
PHI |
3 |
|
 |
5-11 |
220 |
28 |
6 |
|
6 |
| |
Staley is apparently on a
three year plan since his two best - and only full 16
game - season came in 1999 and 2002 during his third and
sixth years. He only managed 29 starts during his other
four years in the NFL. Staying healthy for the entire
season was an accomplishment and he produced 1570 yards
and eight touchdowns but five of those were after McNabb
was injured in week 10. The original plan in 2002 was
to have Buckhalter run and Staley catch and a smattering
of other runningbacks picking up the crumbs. Buckhalter
made that moot when he lost all last season recovering
from a knee injury. Staley was his inconsistent self last
season, totaling over 100 yards in seven games but failing
to reach 75 yards in eight games. Staley is a smart, all-purpose
RB that figures prominently into the passing game and
can sometimes turn in a big rushing effort against even
quality opponents. But he is hurt with the diversity of
the Eagle's attack and their propensity to use McNabb
or even possibly Buckhalter to score short touchdowns.
Look for Staley to slide back this year as others take
more of the rushing load and hope that his medical file
gets no bigger this season.
Lowered (08/04/03) - Staley continues to
be a holdout in the Eagles camp which is mostly serving
to make HC Andy Reid mad and damage Staley's standing
on the team. Reid has already said that Staley will lose
the starting job if he is not in camp and there is conjecture
that Staley will not be with the team next year after
his current contract expires. Lowered (08/15/03)
- Still holding out and making Andy Reid even more mad,
Staley is coming to a point of no return... literally.
His bargaining position may be lifted a little with the
injury to Westbrook, but by this point it will be hard
to uncross Reid's arms and get back into good graces.
Update (08/24/03) - Staley has now ended his holdout
and reported back to the Eagles. It remains to be seen
how much his role will be changed this season, but it
was already planned to use Buckhalter more and Staley
still does not seem slated for any future with Philadelphia. |
| |
33 |
Smith, Onterrio |
MIN |
6 |
|
|
5-10 |
220 |
22 |
R |
|
6 |
| |
Smith was a highly ranked
RB that fell to the fourth round where the Vikings selected
him with their 4.08 pick. Fast and shifty, Smith should
see some special teams duty while Michael Bennett and
Moe Williams take care of that whole running thing. Some
in the Vikings organization think that if Smith can practice
to form this summer, he may take some snaps away from
Moe Bennett. Smith is a slashing, between-the-tackles
runner than complements Bennett's home run ability. Rose
82nd to 48th (7/9/03) - With Michael Bennett potentially
sidelined, the rookie running back from Oregon suddenly
looks to have at least a limited chance to play. Could
this be the hot rookie RB for the year? Smith is actually
as good a runner as Bennett, with the exception of being
slightly less fast (as almost all RBs would be). Training
camp for the Vikings just got interesting.
Rose 48th to 32nd (7/27/03) - This is a
risky move up since Smith still has not been annointed
the starter but but of all Viking's RB's, Smith has the
most upside and seems the best potential replacement for
Bennett. If you make this play, you should probably back
yourself up with getting Chapman as well. Going into training
camp, Smith is the better bet but by no means a certainty.
He just signed so now the work begins. Lowered 31st
to 34th (08/04/03) - The running back picture in MIN
continues to be muddled with Williams, Smith, Chapman
and even Ned in the picture. For a homerun swing, Smith
is still the best bet to replace Bennett and produce big
numbers but there is obvious risk. Raised 34th to 32nd
- Smith is back higher again with the news from MIN that
he is looking sharper than the rest of the backs and that
he appears to have a line on the starting RB job. |
| |
34 |
Williams, Moe |
MIN |
6 |
|
|
6-1 |
210 |
28 |
7 |
|
6 |
| |
In this era of specialists,
Williams was not a starter in any game last season but
typically had five or six carries a game. He ended the
season with 414 yards on 84 carries with 11 touchdowns
that he basically took away from Michael Bennett. Williams
scored in nine different games and will continue to play
the short yardage role. He is an excellent #4 RB to draft
and a decent #3 RB since he scores so often. Rose 38th
to 34nd (7/9/03) - Thanks to the questions now swirling
around Michael Bennett, Moe Williams at the goal line
looks even more attractive. Rose 34th to 31st (8/3/03)
- According to the coaching staff, If the season started
today - Williams would be the starter. But regardless,
Williams is the only constant in the mess of running backs
and the only guarantee to get carries. |
| |
35 |
Alstott, Mike |
TB |
4 |
 |
|
6-1 |
248 |
29 |
7 |
|
4 |
| |
Don't expect to see a lot
of Alstott in training camp. With a history of hamstring
problems, Gruden allowed Alstott to take it lightly last
summer and he did make it all 16 games last season. With
the Michael Pittman legal problems, it would be nice to
get a better glimpse of what the backfield will be this
year but do not count on a clear picture by September.
Tampa Bay won the Superbowl with minimal rushing all season
and made no significant moves to bring in new players
so far. By default, Alstott is clearly the most veteran
RB on the roster and most likely to see an increase but
the most bankable bump is likely with red zone carries.
Alstott is continually about a 600/200 player with five
or six scores each season. That is a nice, though minor,
filler for a bye week. |
| |
36 |
Bettis, Jerome |
PIT |
7 |
 |
 |
5-11 |
256 |
31 |
10 |
|
4 |
| |
After 10 seasons, 2873 carries
and 149 games, there are a lot of reasons to downgrade
Bettis who has started only 11 games a season the past
two years. While space is quickly filling on the Zereoue
bandwagon, consider a few things before you pop big money
for a window seat. Bettis scored nine touchdowns last
year - his second best of his career. He has relatively
no receptions to factor into the equation and he did have
his second worst yardage output. But Bettis struggled
with a knee injury most of the year, missing four games
and playing limited in others. Don't write him off quite
yet though. While rumors speculated he would be cut June
1st, he wasn't. In mini-camp he not only looked healthy
and sharp, but in run drills actually led Zereoue. At
256 pounds, Bettis is the perfect goal line basher, but
he also scored on 24 and 46 yard runs last season. While
Cowher hinted at the end of last season Bettis could get
cut, he now says Bettis is still in the mix and by not
taking a rookie RB in the draft, the Steelers will again
go with Bettis, Zereoue and Fuamatu-Ma'afala. If Bettis
remains healthy, there is no reason why he will not perform
much better than this ranking, especially considering
the passing game that has developed in PIT. But his risk
of injury from age and experience, and the very real risk
of RBBC in PIT makes him worthy of rounding out the final
starters in your league. Update (08/20/03) - With
Zereoue as the named starting running back for the Steelers,
Bettis obviously must fall but unlike other situations,
it is safe to assume that Bettis does not spend the entire
season on the bench. His role is still not as defined
in terms of short yardage and goal line runs and he has
been in great shape this summer. Cowher's decision was
a good one - aiming more towards the future and finding
a better fit for the new passing offense of the Steelers
instead of the old grind-it-out style that Bettis employs. |
| |
37 |
Duckett, T.J. |
ATL |
8 |
 |
 |
6-0 |
254 |
22 |
1 |
|
4 |
| |
The first round pick by the
Falcons came into the league as a bruiser with speed.
Problem was that he did quickly was to get bruised himself.
Duckett missed four games due to injury and was limited
in a couple more last season. While the Falcons were interested
in seeing what their big back could do last season, fantasy
fans are still waiting for a true picture. Duckett gained
only 507 yards rushing in 2002 and was virtually nonexistent
in the passing game. He is worth a pick here from his
opportunity and the expectations that he has yet to fulfill.
Duckett is also expected to get more play in replacing
the production of FB Bob Christian who retired in the
offseason. An upgraded passing attack in Atlanta may help
but consider Duckett a risk until he can prove to be able
to give and not take a pounding of the NFL. |
|
38 |
Gary, Olandis |
DET |
6 |
|
|
5-11 |
218 |
28 |
4 |
|
4 |
| |
Gary has limited appeal backing
up Travis Henry and knowing that McGahee gets some carries
should be manage to be healthy enough by the late part
of the season. Just a backup. Update
(08/31/03) - Gary improves in the rankings with the
trade to Detroit. Stewart will be out for a few more weeks
most likely and Gary still has to learn the new offense,
but it is a similar variant of the West Coast scheme he
already knows. Add in a less than durable Stewart and
Gary has a shot at some playing time. Update
(09/02/03) - With Stewart
gone, Gary will be mixed in with Shawn Bryson and to a
lesser extent Avon Cobourne to determine who, if anyone,
emerges as a primary back. Temper you expectations with
Gary as he has proven to be injury prone and has not been
nearly as effective since blowing out his knee a few years
ago. |
|
39 |
Bryson, Shawn |
DET |
6 |
 |
|
6-1 |
228 |
26 |
3 |
|
4 |
| |
Bryson was has always been
an enigma. He was a fullback coming out of college and
yet is always one of the fastest players on his team.
As a rookie, he platooned with Sammy Morris and Antowain
Smith and had better yardage than either. In limited play
he still had 32 catches for 271 yards and two touchdowns,
and gained 591 yards on 161 carries. The next season he
mixed with Travis Henry, later giving way to him even
though Bryson had a 4.3 yard rushing average compared
to Henry's 3.4 YPC. He fell to only 80 carries for 341
yards and only received nine passes in 2001. He did score
a 68 yard touchdown because he has jets down the sidelines.
In 2002, Henry completely took over, making him expendable
this season. The Lions picked him up as a backup to Stewart
this year along with draft pick Artose Pinner who was
taken with their 4.02 selection. Bryson has not received
a full load in his career and yet still has shown great
speed, balance and power. He will be backing up the aging
and oft-injured James Stewart which makes him an intriguing
pick here. Update
(08/28/03) - Bryson has taken so long to return from
injury that he is still a bigger unknown in the Detroit
offense than the higher ranking warranted. While James
Stewart is no model of durability, neither has been Bryson.
Update (08/29/03) - The ink was not even
wet from dropping him last night and James Stewart separated
his shoulder making him a factor again. Bryson is next
in line though he is returning slowly from a knee injury
last year. With only Avon Cobourne to battle with, Bryson
as the veteran is the most likely option to replace Stewart
though Detroit could look for a free agent or trade to
cure their sudden hole. Update
(09/02/03) - Bryson will
compete with Gary for the starting nod and he too is coming
back from a knee injury. As of now, Gary has the perceived
edge though not a great one. |
| |
40 |
Shipp, Marcel |
ARZ |
7 |
 |
|
5-11 |
226 |
24 |
2 |
|
2 |
| |
Before someone in the ARZ
front office slapped their forehead and said "Hey
- what about Emmitt?", fantasy fans were encouraged
with the performance of Shipp last season when he exceeded
100 total yards seven times even though he officially
started only six games. Shipp not only has good size,
but has speed as well evidenced by his runs of 39, 40
and 56 yards. He was rewarded with a four year contract
for $8 million before the 2002 season ended. And then
came Emmitt. Shipp is a great pick in a keeper or dynasty
league and still a worthwhile addition this year even
if Emmitt goes all 16 games since Shipp will be a change
of pace back with almost certain short yardage opportunities. |
| |
41 |
Jordan, LaMont |
NYJ |
5 |
 |
|
5-10 |
230 |
24 |
2 |
|
2 |
| |
Last season Jordan's per yard
rushing average fell from 7.5 as a rookie to 3.8, but
much of that is a product of his use in short yardage
situations. Jordan is a powerful back with decent speed
who is basically twiddling his thumbs waiting for Curtis
Martin to slow down or cost too much to keep. Martin is
such a warrior that he played injured much of last season
and Jordan's value is low to all except the Martin owner
in your league. |
| |
42 |
Peterson, Adrian |
CHI |
3 |
 |
|
5-10 |
208 |
23 |
1 |
|
2 |
| |
After gaining 101 yards on
only 19 carries last season, Peterson enters training
camp with an outside shot to unseat the underperforming
Anthony Thomas this season. While it is worthless to evaluate
a player based on 19 carries in a season, Peterson fell
to the 6th round in last year's draft largely because
he had no receiving experience at Georgia Southern and
ran a 4.65 at the combine. But he was productive in college
and is known as a hard runner with some quickness that
can break tackles in spite of his lesser size. He is a
scrapper who will give Thomas a run for the summer. Since
Chicago was dead last in the league for rushing yards
in 2002, that constant change at RB for the Bears may
not yet be over. Bar trivia - his brother is LB Mike Peterson
now with the Jaguars (was IND). |
| |
43 |
Faulk, Kevin |
NE |
10 |
|
|
5-8 |
202 |
27 |
4 |
|
2 |
| |
Faulk is mainly used to rest
Antowain Smith and last season normally carried the ball
about four times a game with decent results but only two
touchdowns for the year. At only 5' 8" and 202 pounds,
Faulk is too small to be a primary back and his value
this season is mostly tied to a running game that will
use him occasionally and may need more if Smith is injured.
In four seasons he has not been able to carry a heavy
load and it is not going to happen now. Raised (08/04/03)
- Faulk gets this bump in light of the news that he
will have his role expanded on the Patriots offense. Raised
(08/15/03) - Faulk will definitely be in the mix
more this season though he will still share with Antowain
Smith. He now makes a decent backup RB for a fantasy team
since he'll be gaining yards each week more consistently
(though not to the level of a starter). |
| |
44 |
White, Jamel |
CLE |
9 |
|
|
5-9 |
208 |
25 |
3 |
|
2 |
| |
With the slow start of William
Green, White was enjoying a great season through the first
nine games as Butch Davis kept reducing Green's touches
and using White more. And then White separated his shoulder
and Green suddenly saw the light. The shoulder caused
him to miss two games and limited him the rest of the
year while Green kept improving. White is smaller than
normal for an every down back and he injured his shoulder
even though he never did exceed twenty touches a game.
The Browns re-signed him to a four year extension last
March and he will continue to provide relief for Green
and some third down duty. In the event Green is injured
or reverts to less effective ways, White can step in and
carry the load for at least a nice stretch of games. |
| |
45 |
Gordon, Lamar |
STL |
5 |
 |
|
6-1 |
214 |
23 |
1 |
|
2 |
| |
While Marshall Faulk was injured
last season, Gordon was only moderately successful. Then
again, the same was true for Faulk in that offense last
year. With Trung Canidate now out of the picture, Lamar
is almost assured two games a year when Faulk is dinged
up. Gordon should be considered at least ten spots earlier
for the Faulk owner in your league and if you hate the
guy that has Faulk, bump him up eleven spots. |
THE REST OF THE RB RANKINGS >>
|
|
|
|