fantasy football     JOIN THE HUDDLE    
HOME ARTICLES NEWS DRAFT GUIDE REGULAR SEASON STATISTICS NFL TEAMS MESSAGE BOARDS

FANTASY FOOTBALL ARTICLES

Official Mock #3 - Performance League - 14 Teams
David M. Dorey
July 28, 2004

This draft was conducted between July 22nd and July 26th considering a performance scoring scenario of 1/10 rush or receive yards, 1/20 pass yards, six point touchdowns with negative two point interceptions. Two point conversions are two points per participant. Defenses receive 1 point per sack, 2 points per turnovers and six point touchdowns.

The 18 rounds built rosters of 2 QB, 5 RB, 5 WR, 2 TE, 2 PK and 2 DEF with a starting lineup of QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, TE, PK and DEF.

Note - this draft was held just prior to George going to the Cowboys, Julius Jones becoming a backup and Ricky Williams deciding he was going to call in sick to work forever.

Draft By Round

Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4
1 RB Holmes, Priest 1 RB Johnson, Rudi 1 WR Johnson, Chad 1 WR Jackson, Darrell
2 RB Tomlinson, Lad. 2 WR Harrison, Marvin 2 RB Jones, Kevin 2 RB Brown, Chris
3 RB Alexander, Shaun 3 RB Faulk, Marshall 3 QB McNabb, Donovan 3 QB Hasselbeck, Matt
4 RB McAllister, Deuce 4 QB Culpepper, Daunte 4 QB Vick, Michael 4 RB Duckett, T.J.
5 RB Green, Ahman 5 RB Bennett, Michael 5 RB Barber, Tiki 5 WR Coles, Laveranues
6 RB Portis, Clinton 6 RB Dillon, Corey 6 TE Gonzalez, Tony 6 WR Smith, Steve
7 RB Williams, Ricky 7 RB Henry, Travis 7 WR Mason, Derrick 7 QB Bulger, Marc
8 RB Taylor, Fred 8 RB Davis, Stephen 8 WR Moss, Santana 8 QB Brooks, Aaron
9 RB Lewis, Jamal 9 QB Manning, Peyton 9 WR Horn, Joe 9 RB Dunn, Warrick
10 RB James, Edgerrin 10 RB Jones, Julius 10 WR Boldin, Anquan 10 WR Johnson, Andre
11 WR Moss, Randy 11 RB Westbrook, Brian 11 RB Martin, Curtis 11 RB Shipp, Marcel
12 RB Davis, Domanick 12 RB Garner, Charlie 12 WR Moulds, Eric 12 WR Walker, Javon
13 RB Barlow, Kevan 13 WR Owens, Terrell 13 RB Staley, Duce 13 QB McNair, Steve
14 WR Holt, Torry 14 WR Ward, Hines 14 RB Jones, Thomas 14 RB Suggs, Lee
Round 5 Round 6 Round 7 Round 8
1 TE Heap, Todd 1 WR Bruce, Isaac 1 RB McGahee, Willis 1 WR Gardner, Rod
2 WR Chambers, Chris 2 WR Stallworth, Donte' 2 WR Lelie, Ashley 2 WR Johnson, Keys.
3 WR Rogers, Charles 3 RB Jackson, Steven 3 PK Vanderjagt, Mike 3 RB Griffin, Quentin
4 TE Shockey, Jeremy 4 TE Winslow, Kellen 4 WR McCareins, Justin 4 WR Williams, Roy
5 QB Green, Trent 5 WR Smith, Rod 5 WR Branch, Deion 5 QB Brady, Tom
6 WR Smith, Jimmy 6 RB Bell, Tatum 6 WR Fitzgerald, Larry 6 QB Plummer, Jake
7 WR Booker, Marty 7 WR McCardell, Keenan 7 DT Patriots 7 DT Ravens
8 WR Robinson, Koren 8 RB Williams, Moe 8 TE Crumpler, Alge 8 WR Morgan, Quincy
9 WR Toomer, Amani 9 WR Porter, Jerry 9 QB Johnson, Brad 9 DT Panthers
10 WR Price, Peerless 10 WR Wayne, Reggie 10 RB Smith, Onterrio 10 QB Garcia, Jeff
11 RB Foster, De'shaun 11 WR Boston, David 11 WR Burress, Plaxico 11 WR Warrick, Peter
12 WR Davis, Andre' 12 WR Robinson, Marcus 12 WR Givens, David 12 RB Smith, Antowain
13 QB Pennington, Chad 13 RB Green, William 13 TE Williams, Boo 13 TE McMichael, Randy
14 QB Favre, Brett 14 RB Buckhalter, Correll 14 RB Wheatley, Tyrone 14 QB Carr, David
Round 9 Round 10 Round 11 Round 12
1 WR Lloyd, Brandon 1 WR Driver, Donald 1 PK Feely, Jay 1 DT Cowboys
2 WR Taylor, Travis 2 RB Hearst, Garrison 2 QB Bledsoe, Drew 2 DT Buccaneers
3 DT Dolphins 3 RB Bettis, Jerome 3 TE Smith, L.J. 3 DT Rams
4 QB McCown, Josh 4 PK Wilkins, Jeff 4 TE Franks, Bubba 4 QB Maddox, Tommy
5 TE Gates, Antonio 5 RB Fargas, Justin 5 WR Gage, Justin 5 WR Hilliard, Ike
6 WR Galloway, Joey 6 TE Witten, Jason 6 RB Morris, Maurice 6 WR Evans, Lee
7 TE Clark, Dallas 7 RB Smith, Emmitt 7 RB Jones, Greg 7 QB Harrington, Joey
8 WR Muhammad, M. 8 RB Alstott, Mike 8 RB Gordon, Lamar 8 WR Ferguson, Robert
9 RB Pittman, Michael 9 RB Dayne, Ron 9 RB Jordan, Lamont 9 PK Akers, David
10 TE Jones, Freddie 10 RB George, Eddie 10 QB Gannon, Rich 10 RB Davenport, Najeh
11 WR Kennison, Eddie 11 RB Thomas, Anthony 11 RB Perry, Chris 11 WR Johnson, Kevin
12 WR Williams, Reggie 12 WR Bennett, Drew 12 TE Clark, Desmond 12 RB Rhodes, Dominic
13 QB Leftwich, Byron 13 WR Morton, Johnnie 13 WR Woods, Rashaun 13 RB Zereoue, Amos
14 TE Kinney, Erron 14 QB Delhomme, Jake 14 RB Minor, Travis 14 WR Bryant, Antonio
Round 13 Round 14 Round 15 Round 16
1 WR Pinkston, Todd 1 RB Betts, Ladell 1 DT Saints 1 DT Packers
2 DT Vikings 2 RB Anderson, Mike 2 PK Carney, John 2 PK Cundiff, Billy
3 PK Vinatieri, Adam 3 WR Washington, Kelley 3 RB Johnson, Larry 3 DT Steelers
4 PK Brown, Josh 4 DT Falcons 4 WR Brown, Troy 4 TE Becht, Anthony
5 WR Glenn, Terry 5 RB Faulk, Kevin 5 DT Chiefs 5 TE Miller, Billy
6 RB Smith, Musa 6 TE Graham, Daniel 6 WR Finneran, Brian 6 DT Bills
7 QB Brunell, Mark 7 RB Hollings, Tony 7 WR Randle El, Antwaan 7 DT Texans
8 WR Bradford, Corey 8 PK Longwell, Ryan 8 TE Troupe, Ben 8 TE Chamberlain, Byron
9 DT Eagles 9 QB Rattay, Tim 9 WR Clayton, Michael 9 PK Stover, Matt
10 PK Elam, Jason 10 TE Pollard, Marcus 10 DT Jaguars 10 DT Seahawks
11 WR Calico, Tyrone 11 WR Northcutt, Dennis 11 RB Pinner, Artose 11 WR Caldwell, Reche
12 QB Palmer, Carson 12 WR McCants, Darnerian 12 PK Gramatica, Martin 12 TE Wilson, Kris
13 WR Reed, Josh 13 TE Stevens, Jerramy 13 DT Titans 13 RB Turner, Michael
14 PK Andersen, Morten 14 DT Lions 14 TE Mili, Itula 14 TE Jolley, Doug
Round 17 Round 18            
1 PK Mare, Olindo 1 PK Hanson, Jason            
2 PK Elling, Aaron 2 TE Johnson, Teyo            
3 DT Bears 3 PK Reed, Jeff            
4 DT Broncos 4 PK Edinger, Paul            
5 PK Kasay, John 5 DT Bengals            
6 DT Colts 6 PK Rackers, Neil            
7 PK Janikowski, Seb. 7 PK Christie, Steve            
8 PK Brown, Kris 8 DT Redskins            
9 PK Nedney, Joe 9 TE Schobel, Matt            
10 PK Brien, Doug 10 PK Dawson, Phil            
11 DT Giants 11 RB Henry, Leonard            
12 TE Kleinsasser, Jim 12 QB Warner, Kurt            
13 PK Hall, John 13 DT Jets            
14 QB Boller, Kyle 14 RB Taylor, Chester            

Draft by Position

Quarterbacks Tight Ends Kickers Team Defense
2.04 Culpepper, Daunte 3.06 Gonzalez, Tony 7.03 Vanderjagt, Mike 7.07 Patriots
2.09 Manning, Peyton 5.01 Heap, Todd 10.04 Wilkins, Jeff 8.07 Ravens
3.03 McNabb, Donovan 5.04 Shockey, Jeremy 11.01 Feely, Jay 8.09 Panthers
3.04 Vick, Michael 6.04 Winslow, Kellen 12.09 Akers, David 9.03 Dolphins
4.03 Hasselbeck, Matt 7.08 Crumpler, Alge 13.03 Vinatieri, Adam 12.01 Cowboys
4.07 Bulger, Marc 7.13 Williams, Boo 13.04 Brown, Josh 12.02 Buccaneers
4.08 Brooks, Aaron 8.13 McMichael, Randy 13.10 Elam, Jason 12.03 Rams
4.13 McNair, Steve 9.05 Gates, Antonio 13.14 Andersen, Morten 13.02 Vikings
5.05 Green, Trent 9.07 Clark, Dallas 14.08 Longwell, Ryan 13.09 Eagles
5.13 Pennington, Chad 9.10 Jones, Freddie 15.02 Carney, John 14.04 Falcons
5.14 Favre, Brett 9.14 Kinney, Erron 15.12 Gramatica, Martin 14.14 Lions
7.09 Johnson, Brad 10.06 Witten, Jason 16.02 Cundiff, Billy 15.01 Saints
8.05 Brady, Tom 11.03 Smith, L.J. 16.09 Stover, Matt 15.05 Chiefs
8.06 Plummer, Jake 11.04 Franks, Bubba 17.01 Mare, Olindo 15.10 Jaguars
8.10 Garcia, Jeff 11.12 Clark, Desmond 17.02 Elling, Aaron 15.13 Titans
8.14 Carr, David 14.06 Graham, Daniel 17.05 Kasay, John 16.01 Packers
9.04 McCown, Josh 14.10 Pollard, Marcus 17.07 Janikowski, Seb. 16.03 Steelers
9.13 Leftwich, Byron 14.13 Stevens, Jerramy 17.08 Brown, Kris 16.06 Bills
10.14 Delhomme, Jake 15.08 Troupe, Ben 17.09 Nedney, Joe 16.07 Texans
11.02 Bledsoe, Drew 15.14 Mili, Itula 17.10 Brien, Doug 16.10 Seahawks
11.10 Gannon, Rich 16.04 Becht, Anthony 17.13 Hall, John 17.03 Bears
12.04 Maddox, Tommy 16.05 Miller, Billy 18.01 Hanson, Jason 17.04 Broncos
12.07 Harrington, Joey 16.08 Chamberlain, Byron 18.03 Reed, Jeff 17.06 Colts
13.07 Brunell, Mark 16.12 Wilson, Kris 18.04 Edinger, Paul 17.11 Giants
13.12 Palmer, Carson 16.14 Jolley, Doug 18.06 Rackers, Neil 18.05 Bengals
14.09 Rattay, Tim 17.12 Kleinsasser, Jim 18.07 Christie, Steve 18.08 Redskins
17.14 Boller, Kyle 18.02 Johnson, Teyo 18.10 Dawson, Phil 18.13 Jets
18.12 Warner, Kurt 18.09 Schobel, Matt        
Running Backs Wide Receivers
1.01 Holmes, Priest 6.13 Green, William 1.11 Moss, Randy 7.11 Burress, Plaxico
1.02 Tomlinson, Lad. 6.14 Buckhalter, Correll 1.14 Holt, Torry 7.12 Givens, David
1.03 Alexander, Shaun 7.01 McGahee, Willis 2.02 Harrison, Marvin 8.01 Gardner, Rod
1.04 McAllister, Deuce 7.10 Smith, Onterrio 2.13 Owens, Terrell 8.02 Johnson, Keys.
1.05 Green, Ahman 7.14 Wheatley, Tyrone 2.14 Ward, Hines 8.04 Williams, Roy
1.06 Portis, Clinton 8.03 Griffin, Quentin 3.01 Johnson, Chad 8.08 Morgan, Quincy
1.07 Williams, Ricky 8.12 Smith, Antowain 3.07 Mason, Derrick 8.11 Warrick, Peter
1.08 Taylor, Fred 9.09 Pittman, Michael 3.08 Moss, Santana 9.01 Lloyd, Brandon
1.09 Lewis, Jamal 10.02 Hearst, Garrison 3.09 Horn, Joe 9.02 Taylor, Travis
1.10 James, Edgerrin 10.03 Bettis, Jerome 3.10 Boldin, Anquan 9.06 Galloway, Joey
1.12 Davis, Domanick 10.05 Fargas, Justin 3.12 Moulds, Eric 9.08 Muhammad, M.
1.13 Barlow, Kevan 10.07 Smith, Emmitt 4.01 Jackson, Darrell 9.11 Kennison, Eddie
2.01 Johnson, Rudi 10.08 Alstott, Mike 4.05 Coles, Laveranues 9.12 Williams, Reggie
2.03 Faulk, Marshall 10.09 Dayne, Ron 4.06 Smith, Steve 10.01 Driver, Donald
2.05 Bennett, Michael 10.10 George, Eddie 4.10 Johnson, Andre 10.12 Bennett, Drew
2.06 Dillon, Corey 10.11 Thomas, Anthony 4.12 Walker, Javon 10.13 Morton, Johnnie
2.07 Henry, Travis 11.06 Morris, Maurice 5.02 Chambers, Chris 11.05 Gage, Justin
2.08 Davis, Stephen 11.07 Jones, Greg 5.03 Rogers, Charles 11.13 Woods, Rashaun
2.10 Jones, Julius 11.08 Gordon, Lamar 5.06 Smith, Jimmy 12.05 Hilliard, Ike
2.11 Westbrook, Brian 11.09 Jordan, Lamont 5.07 Booker, Marty 12.06 Evans, Lee
2.12 Garner, Charlie 11.11 Perry, Chris 5.08 Robinson, Koren 12.08 Ferguson, Robert
3.02 Jones, Kevin 11.14 Minor, Travis 5.09 Toomer, Amani 12.11 Johnson, Kevin
3.05 Barber, Tiki 12.10 Davenport, Najeh 5.10 Price, Peerless 12.14 Bryant, Antonio
3.11 Martin, Curtis 12.12 Rhodes, Dominic 5.12 Davis, Andre' 13.01 Pinkston, Todd
3.13 Staley, Duce 12.13 Zereoue, Amos 6.01 Bruce, Isaac 13.05 Glenn, Terry
3.14 Jones, Thomas 13.06 Smith, Musa 6.02 Stallworth, Donte' 13.08 Bradford, Corey
4.02 Brown, Chris 14.01 Betts, Ladell 6.05 Smith, Rod 13.11 Calico, Tyrone
4.04 Duckett, T.J. 14.02 Anderson, Mike 6.07 McCardell, Keenan 13.13 Reed, Josh
4.09 Dunn, Warrick 14.05 Faulk, Kevin 6.09 Porter, Jerry 14.03 Washington, Kelley
4.11 Shipp, Marcel 14.07 Hollings, Tony 6.10 Wayne, Reggie 14.11 Northcutt, Dennis
4.14 Suggs, Lee 15.03 Johnson, Larry 6.11 Boston, David 14.12 McCants, Darnerian
5.11 Foster, De'shaun 15.11 Pinner, Artose 6.12 Robinson, Marcus 15.04 Brown, Troy
6.03 Jackson, Steven 16.13 Turner, Michael 7.02 Lelie, Ashley 15.06 Finneran, Brian
6.06 Bell, Tatum 18.11 Henry, Leonard 7.04 McCareins, Justin 15.07 Randle El, Antwaan
6.08 Williams, Moe 18.14 Taylor, Chester 7.05 Branch, Deion 15.09 Clayton, Michael
        7.06 Fitzgerald, Larry 16.11 Caldwell, Reche

Resulting Teams

Draft Slot #1
5 Round Strategy: RB, WR, WR, RB, TE

Began naturally with Priest Holmes and then went the WR-WR route with the next two picks netting Ward and Chad Johnson. That looks pretty nice on paper to start with but in a league of 14 teams, RB's are even more valuable and waiting until the 4.14 pick meant 31 backs were gone and team took the shot on Lee Suggs which is a big risk. May pay off or he may just relieve William Green. In the 5th round went with Todd Heap as a nice value pick but bypassed Trent Green, Favre and Pennington. Heap makes a difference as a TE, but the scoring is nowhere near as high as dropping down for QB. He later took David Carr in the 8th round which ensures one of his highest scoring positions will likely be below average and maybe not even starter material on other teams.

Getting Buckhalter (6th) was nice to insure the Suggs pick. The plan looked like it got caught in the 4th needing a RB and he just missed out on Shipp and Dunn which would be less risky. Big team at RB1, WR1, WR2 and TE, but lacks at QB and RB2. One injury to Holmes and this team will hurt big time with no way to cover. This entire team took a different direction with the tempting pick of Chad Johnson in the 3rd.

Starters: Carr, Holmes, Suggs, Ward, C. Johnson, Lloyd, Heap, Feely and DET.

Grade: C+

 
# Draft tea baggers
1.01 RB Holmes,Priest QB Carr,David
2.14 WR Ward,Hines QB Delhomme,Jake
3.01 WR Johnson,Chad RB Holmes,Priest
4.14 RB Suggs,Lee RB Suggs,Lee
5.01 TE Heap,Todd RB Buckhalter,Correll
6.14 RB Buckhalter,Correll RB McGahee,Willis
7.01 RB McGahee,Willis RB Taylor,Chester
8.14 QB Carr,David WR Ward,Hines
9.01 WR Lloyd,Brandon WR Johnson,Chad
10.14 QB Delhomme,Jake WR Lloyd,Brandon
11.01 PK Feely,Jay WR Bryant,Antonio
12.14 WR Bryant,Antonio WR Pinkston,Todd
13.01 WR Pinkston,Todd TE Heap,Todd
14.14 DT Lions TE Jolley,Doug
15.01 DT Saints PK Feely,Jay
16.14 TE Jolley,Doug PK Mare,Olindo
17.01 PK Mare,Olindo DT Lions
18.14 RB Taylor,Chester DT Saints
     

Draft Slot #2
5 Round Strategy: RB, WR, RB, QB, WR

After snatching Tomlinson, went with best player on the board of Owens and then wisely grabbed a 2nd RB with Kevin Jones with the 3rd pick. Found Steve McNair in the 4th and then wrapped up the first 5 rounds with a nice pick of Chambers for his WR2.

Team decided to get some RB depth - always a nice idea but in a league this large, the 6.13 produced only William Green who like Suggs above may be a gem or a dud. Rounded out the high scoring positions with Lelie in the 7th and got McMichael at the 8.13 as the final low risk TE. This plan worked pretty well in securing a solid QB, RB1, WR1, WR2 and TE with upside to RB2. In a big league, this is very good and was aided some by a few players falling to him.

Starters: McNair, Tomlinson, K Jones, Owens, Chambers, Lelie, McMichael, Carney and MIN.

Grade: A-

 
# Draft Limburger Melons
1.02 RB Tomlinson,Ladainian QB McNair,Steve
2.13 WR Owens,Terrell QB Bledsoe,Drew
3.02 RB Jones,Kevin RB Tomlinson,Ladainian
4.13 QB McNair,Steve RB Jones,Kevin
5.02 WR Chambers,Chris RB Green,William
6.13 RB Green,William RB Zereoue,Amos
7.02 WR Lelie,Ashley RB Turner,Michael
8.13 TE McMichael,Randy WR Owens,Terrell
9.02 WR Taylor,Travis WR Chambers,Chris
10.13 WR Morton,Johnnie WR Lelie,Ashley
11.02 QB Bledsoe,Drew WR Taylor,Travis
12.13 RB Zereoue,Amos WR Morton,Johnnie
13.02 DT Vikings TE McMichael,Randy
14.13 TE Stevens,Jerramy TE Stevens,Jerramy
15.02 PK Carney,John PK Carney,John
16.13 RB Turner,Michael PK Elling,Aaron
17.02 PK Elling,Aaron DT Vikings
18.13 DT Jets DT Jets
     

Draft Slot #3
5 Round Strategy: RB, RB, QB, WR, WR

This is a generally sound plan, so it is interesting to see how it applies to a 14 team league. Started with Alexander and then opted for Garner before the RB's were further decimated. Picked up McNabb (3rd) and probably could have been stronger with Mason there and McNair later, but with 22 picks to go, it was a reasonable move to ensure a top QB. Went straight after WR for next three rounds with Javon Walker, Charles Rogers and Marcus Robinson.

Very aggressive with Vanderjagt in the 7th when the 2nd kicker taken waited until the 10th. Probably would have been better off with Alge Crumpler or Boo Williams there. The Miami pick was also likely a full round or more early. It is great to take difference makers but it is a gambling game when you bypass high scoring backups to take them. Near the ends of either rounds forces a calculated risk in picks which sometimes prove unnecessarily early.

Overall, ended up with a great QB, RB1, and PK and has some depth. TE's are likely weak and as it ended up, WR's will likely struggle to be average. This strategy is sound generally but shows how the larger league waters down the talent and a few picks were made too early.

Starters: McNabb, Alexander, Garner, Walker, Rogers, Robinson, L.J. Smith, Vanderjagt and MIA

Grade : B+

 
# Draft Pigskin Posse
1.03 RB Alexander,Shaun QB McNabb,Donovan
2.12 RB Garner,Charlie QB Warner,Kurt
3.03 QB McNabb,Donovan RB Alexander,Shaun
4.12 WR Walker,Javon RB Garner,Charlie
5.03 WR Rogers,Charles RB Smith,Antowain
6.12 WR Robinson,Marcus RB Rhodes,Dominic
7.03 PK Vanderjagt,Mike RB Johnson,Larry
8.12 RB Smith,Antowain WR Walker,Javon
9.03 DT Dolphins WR Rogers,Charles
10.12 WR Bennett,Drew WR Robinson,Marcus
11.03 TE Smith,L.J. WR Bennett,Drew
12.12 RB Rhodes,Dominic WR McCants,Darnerian
13.03 PK Vinatieri,Adam TE Smith,L.J.
14.12 WR McCants,Darnerian TE Wilson,Kris
15.03 RB Johnson,Larry PK Vanderjagt,Mike
16.12 TE Wilson,Kris PK Vinatieri,Adam
17.03 DT Bears DT Dolphins
18.12 QB Warner,Kurt DT Bears
     

Draft Slot #4
5 Round Strategy: RB, RB, QB, RB, TE

Went with McAllister and then scooped up Brian Westbrook (2nd) before using the 3.04 on Vick. The 4th round pick was Shipp for RB3 before any WR or TE were taken and while Shipp could be nice, he passed on Walker and Chambers who would have contributed every week. Took Shockey (5th) for a nice value pick and then by necessity went on the three WR string of Boston, McCareins and Warrick.

Forgot the roster requirements and only took one PK and DT which may be realistic but in a league this large, there is much less on the FA wire to grab when needed - only 5 PK or DEF were left undrafted. Solid at QB, RB and TE, the receivers ended up weaker and then the PK and DT shortfalls could hurt. The bigger the league, the more balance usually helps but by the same token, the more the high scorers like Vick or McAllister help out. Will hurt for WR depth.

Starters: Vick, McAllister, Westbrook, Boston, McCareins, Warrick, Shockey, Brown and DEN.

Grade : C

 
# Draft Wolverines
1.04 RB McAllister,Deuce QB Vick,Michael
2.11 RB Westbrook,Brian QB McCown,Josh
3.04 QB Vick,Michael RB McAllister,Deuce
4.11 RB Shipp,Marcel RB Westbrook,Brian
5.04 TE Shockey,Jeremy RB</