fantasy football     JOIN THE HUDDLE    
HOME ARTICLES NEWS DRAFT GUIDE REGULAR SEASON STATISTICS NFL TEAMS MESSAGE BOARDS

FANTASY FOOTBALL ARTICLES

Official Mock #11 - Performance scoring / Reception Points / Flex - 12 Teams
David M. Dorey
August 26, 2004

This draft was conducted between August 23rd and August 25th considering a performance scoring scenario of 1/10 rush or receive yards, 1/20 pass yards, six point touchdowns with negative two point interceptions. Two point conversions are two points per participant. DEFenses receive 1 point per sack, 2 points per turnovers and six point touchdowns.

Each reception received one point.

The 18 rounds built rosters of 2 QB, 5 RB, 5 WR, 2 TE, 2 PK and 2 DEF with a starting lineup of QB, 2 RB, 3 WR, 1 Flex (RB, WR or TE), TE, PK and DEF.

Draft By Round

Round 1 Round 2 Round 3 Round 4
1 RB Tomlinson,Lad. 1 RB Barlow,Kevan 1 WR Mason,Derrick 1 RB Staley,Duce
2 RB Holmes,Priest 2 RB Johnson,Rudi 2 RB Bennett,Michael 2 WR Smith,Steve
3 RB Green,Ahman 3 RB Faulk,Marshall 3 WR Horn,Joe 3 WR Jackson,Darrell
4 RB McAllister,Deuce 4 RB Davis,Domanick 4 RB Barber,Tiki 4 WR Chambers,Chris
5 RB Alexander,Shaun 5 RB Dillon,Corey 5 RB Henry,Travis 5 WR Johnson,Andre
6 WR Moss,Randy 6 QB Culpepper,Daunte 6 RB Jones,Thomas 6 RB Jones,Kevin
7 RB James,Edgerrin 7 TE Gonzalez,Tony 7 WR Moss,Santana 7 WR Coles,Laveranues
8 RB Lewis,Jamal 8 QB Manning,Peyton 8 WR Moulds,Eric 8 RB Duckett,T.J.
9 RB Portis,Clinton 9 WR Owens,Terrell 9 RB Brown,Chris 9 WR Toomer,Amani
10 WR Holt,Torry 10 RB Davis,Stephen 10 RB Westbrook,Brian 10 WR Booker,Marty
11 RB Taylor,Fred 11 WR Johnson,Chad 11 WR Walker,Javon 11 QB Vick,Michael
12 WR Harrison,Marvin 12 WR Ward,Hines 12 RB Martin,Curtis 12 TE Heap,Todd
Round 5 Round 6 Round 7 Round 8
1 RB Garner,Charlie 1 WR Burress,Plaxico 1 RB Minor,Travis 1 QB Brady,Tom
2 WR Robinson,Koren 2 QB Bulger,Marc 2 WR Fitzgerald,Larry 2 WR Morgan,Quincy
3 QB McNabb,Donovan 3 WR Rogers,Charles 3 WR Wayne,Reggie 3 TE Gates,Antonio
4 RB Dunn,Warrick 4 QB McNair,Steve 4 QB Brooks,Aaron 4 WR Lelie,Ashley
5 WR Price,Peerless 5 QB Pennington,Chad 5 WR Branch,Deion 5 TE Kinney,Erron
6 QB Hasselbeck,Matt 6 WR Bruce,Isaac 6 RB Jackson,Steven 6 RB Jones,Julius
7 RB Suggs,Lee 7 RB McGahee,Willis 7 WR Johnson,Keys. 7 RB Bell,Tatum
8 WR Davis,Andre' 8 WR Stallworth,Donte' 8 RB George,Eddie 8 WR McCareins,Justin
9 WR Smith,Jimmy 9 TE Williams,Boo 9 TE McMichael,Randy 9 WR McCardell,Keenan
10 RB Wheatley,Tyrone 10 TE Winslow,Kellen 10 QB Favre,Brett 10 WR Kennison,Eddie
11 TE Shockey,Jeremy 11 RB Foster,De'shaun 11 RB Griffin,Quentin 11 DEF Ravens
12 WR Porter,Jerry 12 QB Green,Trent 12 TE Crumpler,Alge 12 WR Smith,Rod
Round 9 Round 10 Round 11 Round 12
1 QB Garcia,Jeff 1 WR Lloyd,Brandon 1 RB Green,William 1 DEF Cowboys
2 TE Clark,Dallas 2 PK Wilkins,Jeff 2 PK Akers,David 2 DEF Vikings
3 RB Dayne,Ron 3 WR Givens,David 3 WR Warrick,Peter 3 DEF Buccaneers
4 WR Gardner,Rod 4 RB Hollings,Tony 4 RB Thomas,Anthony 4 QB Leftwich,Byron
5 DEF Patriots 5 WR Ferguson,Robert 5 TE Witten,Jason 5 QB Palmer,Carson
6 PK Vanderjagt,Mike 6 DEF Rams 6 QB Johnson,Brad 6 QB Plummer,Jake
7 TE Jones,Freddie 7 WR Terrell,David 7 WR Muhammad,M. 7 WR Galloway,Joey
8 RB Bettis,Jerome 8 WR Boldin,Anquan 8 WR Gage,Justin 8 RB Jordan,Lamont
9 WR Williams,Roy 9 WR Clayton,Michael 9 RB Smith,Onterrio 9 QB Delhomme,Jake
10 RB Williams,Moe 10 DEF Panthers 10 RB Harris,Arlen 10 RB Levens,Dorsey
11 WR Robinson,Marcus 11 WR Driver,Donald 11 RB Pittman,Michael 11 WR Rice,Jerry
12 RB Smith,Emmitt 12 WR Glenn,Terry 12 QB Carr,David 12 DEF Dolphins
Round 13 Round 14 Round 15 Round 16
1 PK Elam,Jason 1 WR Northcutt,Dennis 1 TE Clark,Desmond 1 WR Engram,Bobby
2 QB Bledsoe,Drew 2 RB Davenport,Najeh 2 RB Fargas,Justin 2 TE Pollard,Marcus
3 PK Feely,Jay 3 PK Longwell,Ryan 3 TE Franks,Bubba 3 TE Smith,L.J.
4 DEF Chiefs 4 WR Calico,Tyrone 4 PK Vinatieri,Adam 4 TE Johnson,Teyo
5 PK Kasay,John 5 WR Dyson,Kevin 5 QB Harrington,Joey 5 RB Smith,Musa
6 WR Burleson,Nate 6 PK Stover,Matt 6 DEF Packers 6 WR Williams,Reggie
7 RB Perry,Chris 7 DEF Falcons 7 TE Becht,Anthony 7 RB Faulk,Kevin
8 DEF Seahawks 8 RB Jackson,James 8 WR Evans,Lee 8 TE Brady,Kyle
9 DEF Eagles 9 RB Alstott,Mike 9 PK Brown,Josh 9 TE Mili,Itula
10 WR Bennett,Drew 10 QB Brunell,Mark 10 QB McCown,Josh 10 RB Taylor,Chester
11 WR Taylor,Travis 11 DEF Titans 11 QB Gannon,Rich 11 TE Kleinsasser,Jim
12 TE Chamberlain,Byron 12 WR Johnson,Bryant 12 DEF Saints 12 RB Smith,Antowain
Round 17 Round 18            
1 DEF Broncos 1 PK Brien,Doug            
2 RB Johnson,Larry 2 DEF Jaguars            
3 PK Carney,John 3 PK Hall,John            
4 PK Nedney,Joe 4 PK Edinger,Paul            
5 PK Janikowski,Se. 5 DEF Colts            
6 PK Gramatica,Martin 6 PK Mare,Olindo            
7 DEF Steelers 7 TE Fitzsimmons,C.            
8 PK Hanson,Jason 8 DEF Jets            
9 DEF Bills 9 DEF Giants            
10 DEF Bears 10 DEF Redskins            
11 PK Elling,Aaron 11 PK Cundiff,Billy            
12 PK Andersen,Morten 12 PK Reed,Jeff            

Draft by Position

Quarterbacks Tight Ends Kickers Team DEFense
2.06 Culpepper,Daunte 2.07 Gonzalez,Tony 9.06 Vanderjagt,Mike 8.11 Ravens
2.08 Manning,Peyton 4.12 Heap,Todd 10.02 Wilkins,Jeff 9.05 Patriots
4.11 Vick,Michael 5.11 Shockey,Jeremy 11.02 Akers,David 10.06 Rams
5.03 McNabb,Donovan 6.09 Williams,Boo 13.01 Elam,Jason 10.10 Panthers
5.06 Hasselbeck,Matt 6.10 Winslow,Kellen 13.03 Feely,Jay 12.01 Cowboys
6.02 Bulger,Marc 7.09 McMichael,Randy 13.05 Kasay,John 12.02 Vikings
6.04 McNair,Steve 7.12 Crumpler,Alge 14.03 Longwell,Ryan 12.03 Buccaneers
6.05 Pennington,Chad 8.03 Gates,Antonio 14.06 Stover,Matt 12.12 Dolphins
6.12 Green,Trent 8.05 Kinney,Erron 15.04 Vinatieri,Adam 13.04 Chiefs
7.04 Brooks,Aaron 9.02 Clark,Dallas 15.09 Brown,Josh 13.08 Seahawks
7.10 Favre,Brett 9.07 Jones,Freddie 17.03 Carney,John 13.09 Eagles
8.01 Brady,Tom 11.05 Witten,Jason 17.04 Nedney,Joe 14.07 Falcons
9.01 Garcia,Jeff 13.12 Chamberlain,Byron 17.05 Janikowski,Se. 14.11 Titans
11.06 Johnson,Brad 15.01 Clark,Desmond 17.06 Gramatica,Martin 15.06 Packers
11.12 Carr,David 15.03 Franks,Bubba 17.08 Hanson,Jason 15.12 Saints
12.04 Leftwich,Byron 15.07 Becht,Anthony 17.11 Elling,Aaron 17.01 Broncos
12.05 Palmer,Carson 16.02 Pollard,Marcus 17.12 Andersen,Morten 17.07 Steelers
12.06 Plummer,Jake 16.03 Smith,L.J. 18.01 Brien,Doug 17.09 Bills
12.09 Delhomme,Jake 16.04 Johnson,Teyo 18.03 Hall,John 17.10 Bears
13.02 Bledsoe,Drew 16.08 Brady,Kyle 18.04 Edinger,Paul 18.02 Jaguars
14.10 Brunell,Mark 16.09 Mili,Itula 18.06 Mare,Olindo 18.05 Colts
15.05 Harrington,Joey 16.11 Kleinsasser,Jim 18.11 Cundiff,Billy 18.08 Jets
15.10 McCown,Josh 18.07 Fitzsimmons,Casey 18.12 Reed,Jeff 18.09 Giants
15.11 Gannon,Rich         18.10 Redskins
               
Running Backs Wide Receivers
1.01 Tomlinson,Lad. 6.11 Foster,De'shaun 1.06 Moss,Randy 8.02 Morgan,Quincy
1.02 Holmes,Priest 7.01 Minor,Travis 1.10 Holt,Torry 8.04 Lelie,Ashley
1.03 Green,Ahman 7.06 Jackson,Steven 1.12 Harrison,Marvin 8.08 McCareins,Justin
1.04 McAllister,Deuce 7.08 George,Eddie 2.09 Owens,Terrell 8.09 McCardell,Keenan
1.05 Alexander,Shaun 7.11 Griffin,Quentin 2.11 Johnson,Chad 8.10 Kennison,Eddie
1.07 James,Edgerrin 8.06 Jones,Julius 2.12 Ward,Hines 8.12 Smith,Rod
1.08 Lewis,Jamal 8.07 Bell,Tatum 3.01 Mason,Derrick 9.04 Gardner,Rod
1.09 Portis,Clinton 9.03 Dayne,Ron 3.03 Horn,Joe 9.09 Williams,Roy
1.11 Taylor,Fred 9.08 Bettis,Jerome 3.07 Moss,Santana 9.11 Robinson,Marcus
2.01 Barlow,Kevan 9.10 Williams,Moe 3.08 Moulds,Eric 10.01 Lloyd,Brandon
2.02 Johnson,Rudi 9.12 Smith,Emmitt 3.11 Walker,Javon 10.03 Givens,David
2.03 Faulk,Marshall 10.04 Hollings,Tony 4.02 Smith,Steve 10.05 Ferguson,Robert
2.04 Davis,Domanick 11.01 Green,William 4.03 Jackson,Darrell 10.07 Terrell,David
2.05 Dillon,Corey 11.04 Thomas,Anthony 4.04 Chambers,Chris 10.08 Boldin,Anquan
2.10 Davis,Stephen 11.09 Smith,Onterrio 4.05 Johnson,Andre 10.09 Clayton,Michael
3.02 Bennett,Michael 11.10 Harris,Arlen 4.07 Coles,Laveranues 10.11 Driver,Donald
3.04 Barber,Tiki 11.11 Pittman,Michael 4.09 Toomer,Amani 10.12 Glenn,Terry
3.05 Henry,Travis 12.08 Jordan,Lamont 4.10 Booker,Marty 11.03 Warrick,Peter
3.06 Jones,Thomas 12.10 Levens,Dorsey 5.02 Robinson,Koren 11.07 Muhammad,Muhsin
3.09 Brown,Chris 13.07 Perry,Chris 5.05 Price,Peerless 11.08 Gage,Justin
3.10 Westbrook,Brian 14.02 Davenport,Najeh 5.08 Davis,Andre' 12.07 Galloway,Joey
3.12 Martin,Curtis 14.08 Jackson,James 5.09 Smith,Jimmy 12.11 Rice,Jerry
4.01 Staley,Duce 14.09 Alstott,Mike 5.12 Porter,Jerry 13.06 Burleson,Nate
4.06 Jones,Kevin 15.02 Fargas,Justin 6.01 Burress,Plaxico 13.10 Bennett,Drew
4.08 Duckett,T.J. 16.05 Smith,Musa 6.03 Rogers,Charles 13.11 Taylor,Travis
5.01 Garner,Charlie 16.07 Faulk,Kevin 6.06 Bruce,Isaac 14.01 Northcutt,Dennis
5.04 Dunn,Warrick 16.10 Taylor,Chester 6.08 Stallworth,Donte' 14.04 Calico,Tyrone
5.07 Suggs,Lee 16.12 Smith,Antowain 7.02 Fitzgerald,Larry 14.05 Dyson,Kevin
5.10 Wheatley,Tyrone 17.02 Johnson,Larry 7.03 Wayne,Reggie 14.12 Johnson,Bryant
6.07 McGahee,Willis     7.05 Branch,Deion 15.08 Evans,Lee
        7.07 Johnson,Keyshawn 16.01 Engram,Bobby
            16.06 Williams,Reggie

Resulting Teams

In evaluating this mock, consider that there is a flex position which is best manned with a RB or a good WR, and there are reception points which elevates the value of receivers and tight ends.

Draft Slot #1
5 Round Strategy: RB, WR, WR, TE, RB

This team used the first pick in the draft to start his RB's off with Tomlinson and then focused on the reception point values of Ward (2), Mason (3) and Heap (4) before finally going back for Garner (5).

Passed by Bennett and other RB's to get Mason which later gave him weaker RB's with Garner and Minor which likely ended up with less net points unless Garner and Minor stay starters and healthy.

Ended up with a Tomlinson and Heap as top players in their position but chased the runs on most other positions and ended with a team likely to produce average points buoyed only by Tomlinson's big games which he would have had anyway. Weaker at RB than desired caused by the attempt to be very strong at WR but that caused a domino effect on the other positions taken. A good effort at using the scoring rules that ended up causing unintended weaknesses at other positions.

Starters: Green, Tomlinson, Garner, Ward, Mason, R Smith, Minor (flex), Heap, Elam, MIA

Grade: C+

 
# Draft Kenny
1.01 RB Tomlinson,Ladainian QB Green,Trent
2.12 WR Ward,Hines QB Garcia,Jeff
3.01 WR Mason,Derrick RB Tomlinson,Ladainian
4.12 TE Heap,Todd RB Garner,Charlie
5.01 RB Garner,Charlie RB Minor,Travis
6.12 QB Green,Trent RB Green,William
7.01 RB Minor,Travis RB Smith,Antowain
8.12 WR Smith,Rod WR Ward,Hines
9.01 QB Garcia,Jeff WR Mason,Derrick
10.12 WR Glenn,Terry WR Smith,Rod
11.01 RB Green,William WR Glenn,Terry
12.12 DEF Dolphins WR Johnson,Bryant
13.01 PK Elam,Jason TE Heap,Todd
14.12 WR Johnson,Bryant TE Clark,Desmond
15.01 TE Clark,Desmond PK Elam,Jason
16.12 RB Smith,Antowain PK Reed,Jeff
17.01 DEF Broncos DEF Dolphins
18.12 PK Reed,Jeff DEF Broncos
     

Draft Slot #2
5 Round Strategy: RB, WR, RB, QB, WR

Took the standard Holmes pick wisely and unlike Team #1, went with best WR in Chad Johnson but then took Bennett off the board to start a solid backfield with one top WR. Used the 4.11 pick to snap up Vick - nice pickup for a quarterback that fell as most do in this scoring system. Went back for Koren Robinson in the 5th.

Ended up with nice starters though his flex position would be either Foster or Driver and neither are that attractive. Solid picks in DEF and PK with upside in Clark for a TE.

The attempt at balance ended up with a good starting crew but almost all backups could be a problem if they were needed. This is a team that would be hunting the waiver for RB, WR and TE most the season probably.

Starters: Vick, Holmes, Bennett, C Johnson, K Robinson, L Fitzgerald, Foster (flex), Dallas Clark, Akers and BAL

Grade: B

 
# Draft Lobsterclaw
1.02 RB Holmes,Priest QB Vick,Michael
2.11 WR Johnson,Chad QB Bledsoe,Drew
3.02 RB Bennett,Michael RB Holmes,Priest
4.11 QB Vick,Michael RB Bennett,Michael
5.02 WR Robinson,Koren RB Foster,De'shaun
6.11 RB Foster,De'shaun RB Fargas,Justin
7.02 WR Fitzgerald,Larry RB Johnson,Larry
8.11 DEF Ravens WR Johnson,Chad
9.02 TE Clark,Dallas WR Robinson,Koren
10.11 WR Driver,Donald WR Fitzgerald,Larry
11.02 PK Akers,David WR Driver,Donald
12.11 WR Rice,Jerry WR Rice,Jerry
13.02 QB Bledsoe,Drew TE Clark,Dallas
14.11 DEF Titans TE Kleinsasser,Jim
15.02 RB Fargas,Justin PK Akers,David
16.11 TE Kleinsasser,Jim PK Cundiff,Billy
17.02 RB Johnson,Larry DEF Ravens
18.11 PK Cundiff,Billy DEF Titans
     

Draft Slot #3
5 Round Strategy: RB, RB, WR, WR, QB

Nice starting RB's with Green and Stephen Davis and followed that with a double dip into WR's that netted Horn and Booker (right before he went south in more ways than one). Wound up with major find of McNabb at the 5.03. Sweet.

Built a team that contained some nice value picks and a few upside shots like Winslow. Did a nice job in grabbing many players that were Top 5 in their position and that should provide some solid weekly points. Like most teams, much of depth would need eventual upgrades.

Starters: McNabb, Green, S Davis, Horn, Booker, Wayne, Dayne/Warrick (flex), Winslow, Feely and CAR.

Grade: B+

 
# Draft FightingEvil
1.03 RB Green,Ahman QB McNabb,Donovan
2.10 RB Davis,Stephen QB Brunell,Mark
3.03 WR Horn,Joe RB Green,Ahman
4.10 WR Booker,Marty RB Davis,Stephen
5.03 QB McNabb,Donovan RB Dayne,Ron
6.10 TE Winslow,Kellen RB Levens,Dorsey
7.03 WR Wayne,Reggie RB Taylor,Chester
8.10 WR Kennison,Eddie WR Horn,Joe
9.03 RB Dayne,Ron WR Booker,Marty
10.10 DEF Panthers WR Wayne,Reggie
11.03 WR Warrick,Peter WR Kennison,Eddie
12.10 RB Levens,Dorsey WR Warrick,Peter
13.03 PK Feely,Jay TE Winslow,Kellen
14.10 QB Brunell,Mark TE Franks,Bubba
15.03 TE Franks,Bubba PK Feely,Jay
16.10 RB Taylor,Chester PK Carney,John
17.03 PK Carney,John DEF Panthers
18.10 DEF Redskins DEF Redskins
     

Draft Slot #4
5 Round Strategy: RB, WR, RB, WR, RB

This plan seemed to work pretty at this slot. Started with McAllister and then got Owens (2). Then back to RB for Barber (3) and then back to WR to get Toomer (4) and then back to RB to still get Dunn (5). Pretty solid start, maybe not spectacular but solid.

Took QB later in the 7th and still got Brooks and took his TE in Boo Williams in the 6th. Elected to wait on DEF and PK and likely has no advantage there and took the big risk on McCardell in the 8th that he probably wishes he had back. It could hit but is looking too risky right now. Nice starters that are at least average and a few that should be in the upper echelon in McAllister, Owens and Williams.

Starters: Brooks, McAllister, Barber, Owens, Toomer, McCardell, Dunn (flex), B WIlliams, Vinatieri and KC.

Grade: B+

 
# Draft Scourge
1.04 RB McAllister,Deuce QB Brooks,Aaron
2.09 WR Owens,Terrell QB Delhomme,Jake
3.04 RB Barber,Tiki RB McAllister,Deuce
4.09 WR Toomer,Amani RB Barber,Tiki
5.04 RB Dunn,Warrick RB Dunn,Warrick
6.09 TE Williams,Boo RB Thomas,Anthony
7.04 QB Brooks,Aaron RB Alstott,Mike
8.09 WR McCardell,Keenan WR Owens,Terrell
9.04 WR Gardner,Rod WR Toomer,Amani
10.09 WR Clayton,Michael WR McCardell,Keenan
11.04 RB Thomas,Anthony WR Gardner,Rod
12.09 QB Delhomme,Jake WR Clayton,Michael
13.04 DEF Chiefs TE Williams,Boo
14.09 RB Alstott,Mike TE Mili,Itula
15.04 PK Vinatieri,Adam PK Vinatieri,Adam
16.09 TE Mili,Itula PK Nedney,Joe
17.04 PK Nedney,Joe DEF Chiefs
18.09 DEF Giants DEF Giants
     

Draft Slot #5
5 Round Strategy: RB, QB, RB, RB, WR

Decided to hit the non-receivers hard at first and after Alexander, grabbed Manning at the 2.08 and then doubled on Henry and Duckett (but missed out on McGahee). Went directly into mining WR's for Price, Stallworth, Branch and McCareins. Upside on all of them and at least three should hit for him.

Took the dive to grab NE at the 9.05 to gain an advantage but the wait until 11th for TE left him only Witten - nice sleeper type but less likely to pay off. Boldin pick in the 10th may pay off nicely at the end of the season. Ended up with a some nice upside on a team that could develop well. Manning and Alexander are the cornerstones and most other picks could outperform where they were chosen. Not a powerhouse team, but one that could grow.

Starters: Manning, Alexander, Henry, Price, Stallworth, Branch, Duckett (flex), Witten, Kasay and NE.

Grade: B

 

 
# Draft Keggerz
1.05 RB Alexander,Shaun QB Manning,Peyton
2.08 QB Manning,Peyton QB Harrington,Joey
3.05 RB Henry,Travis RB Alexander,Shaun
4.08 RB Duckett,T.J. RB Henry,Travis
5.05 WR Price,Peerless RB Duckett,T.J.
6.08 WR Stallworth,Donte' RB Jordan,Lamont
7.05 WR Branch,Deion RB Jackson,James
8.08 WR McCareins,Justin WR Price,Peerless
9.05 DEF Patriots WR Stallworth,Donte'
10.08 WR Boldin,Anquan WR Branch,Deion
11.05 TE Witten,Jason WR McCareins,Justin
12.08 RB Jordan,Lamont WR Boldin,Anquan
13.05 PK Kasay,John TE Witten,Jason
14.08 RB Jackson,James TE Brady,Kyle
15.05 QB Harrington,Joey PK Kasay,John
16.08 TE Brady,Kyle PK Janikowski,Sebas.
17.05 PK Janikowski,Sebas. DEF